Earmark CPE

Earn CPE Anytime, Anywhere

Blake Oliver

The Accounting Profession at a Crossroads: Adapting to Stay Relevant in a Changing Business Landscape

· ·

The accounting profession is at a critical juncture. Technology is rapidly transforming the business landscape. As client needs evolve and new skill sets become essential, CPAs must ask themselves: Are we keeping pace with change, or are we at risk of becoming irrelevant?

In this thought-provoking Earmark Podcast episode, I explore the evolving role and relevance of the CPA license with Steven Sacks, a consultant who serves professional service firms and not-for-profit organizations, and David Bergstein, a seasoned innovator in the accounting software industry. Our discussion reveals that to remain relevant and valuable in today’s rapidly changing business landscape, the accounting profession must adapt its education, licensure, and skill development to align with the evolving needs of clients and employers.

Bridging the Gap Between Accounting Education and Real-world Skills

There’s a growing disconnect between traditional accounting education and job market demands. David Bergstein points out, “Accounting education focuses heavily on debits, credits, and accounting standards but does not adequately prepare students with technology skills and business advisory knowledge needed in the real world.”

For example, many young professionals struggle to apply their classroom knowledge to real-world situations. They may have learned how to do t-accounts and journal entries but never touched modern accounting software like QuickBooks or Xero during their education.

Bridging the education-skills gap is crucial for the CPA profession to adapt to the changing needs of clients and employers and maintain its relevance in the business world. This may involve:

  • Incorporating more hands-on, technology-focused training into accounting curricula, such as working with modern accounting software like QuickBooks, Xero, or Sage
  • Partnering with businesses to provide internships and real-world experience for students
  • Encouraging faculty to stay up-to-date with the latest industry trends and tools
  • Emphasizing the development of soft skills, such as communication and critical thinking, alongside technical knowledge

By aligning accounting education with the realities of modern practice, the CPA profession can ensure its future members have the skills and knowledge they need to succeed in a rapidly evolving business landscape.

Reimagining CPA Licensure for a Diverse Profession

As the roles and expertise of CPAs become increasingly diverse, the profession must reevaluate its licensure model to ensure it reflects the realities of modern accounting practice.  

Steven Sacks emphasizes the need for greater clarity around the CPA’s role and definition: “If you really want to increase the pool of CPAs, define what the CPA is, what it means. Define the definition of the practice of public accounting. What is public accounting? What are accounting services? There are a lot of things that are really not clear.”

The disconnect between the CPA license and the day-to-day work of many accountants raises important questions about the credential’s relevance and value. As I point out in the episode, “What does the license actually give us a franchise on or a monopoly over? The only thing is the audit.”

Embracing Alternative Certifications and Career Paths

Our discussion reveals a growing trend of accounting professionals, particularly younger generations, pursuing non-traditional roles and credentials to build successful careers.

David Bergstein shares his observations: “I’m seeing the younger generation not become CPAs and become advisors or accountants. Non-CPAs have tremendous practices out there. They have very lucrative practices. They’re in their 30s and 40s. For the most part, they didn’t pursue an accounting career. They took very few accounting courses. Now, they’re quarterbacking firms and hiring some CPAs, but mainly accountants and non-accountants. They’re doing managerial reports and partial CFO services with a data analytics background.”

This shift in career trajectories reflects a growing recognition that the traditional CPA path may not fit everyone best. Instead, many aspiring accountants opt for alternative certifications, such as the Certified Management Accountant (CMA) or the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA), which better align with their career goals and interests.

A Call to Action: Shaping the Future of the CPA Profession

Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or a new graduate just starting your career, you can shape the direction and impact of the CPA credential for generations to come.

So, what can you do to help drive positive change and ensure the profession’s continued success? Here are a few suggestions:

  • Advocate for educational reforms that prioritize real-world skills and hands-on learning experiences
  • Support efforts to modernize CPA licensure requirements and create new pathways for non-audit professionals
  • Explore alternative certifications and career paths that align with your unique interests and goals
  • Engage in meaningful continuing education that expands your knowledge and keeps you at the forefront of industry trends
  • Collaborate with colleagues and professional organizations to share ideas, best practices, and innovative solutions
  • Educate clients, employers, and the public about the diverse capabilities and expertise of CPAs beyond traditional audit services

By embracing change, innovation, and diversity, the CPA profession can chart a course toward a brighter future—one in which CPAs are recognized as trusted advisors, strategic partners, and indispensable experts in a wide range of financial and business disciplines.

The accounting profession is at a crossroads, and our choices today will shape its future. By adapting our education, licensure, and skill development to align with the evolving needs of clients and employers, we can ensure that CPAs remain relevant, valuable, and indispensable in a rapidly changing business landscape. To dive deeper into this critical conversation about the future of the CPA profession, listen to the full Earmark Podcast episode.

Earn free CPE for listening to “Who’s Really the BOSS”

· ·

Join me in welcoming the “Who’s Really the BOSS?” show to the Earmark app. Earn free CPE listening!

This podcast by Marcus Dillon, CPA, and Rachel Dillon highlights the joys and challenges of running a CPA firm with your spouse.

In the first course, “The Secret to a Successful Accounting Firm,” Bruce D. Berndt, CPA, CGMA, shares his top two pieces of advice for building a thriving firm focused on exceptional client service and a positive team culture.

The Cloud Accounting Revolution

To understand the potential impact of AI, it’s essential to look back at how cloud accounting transformed the industry. Cloud accounting reduced the time for traditional accounting and bookkeeping work by 80-90%. It forced firms like mine to adapt their business models and pricing strategies to remain competitive. 

As I mentioned in the podcast, “My career was in outsourced accounting. Cloud-based accounting cuts the time required to do traditional accounting and bookkeeping work by 80 to 90%. I couldn’t bill by the hour. If I did, I would not have a business.”

AI: The Next Frontier of Productivity

AI advancements in banking and accounting already show remarkable potential to boost productivity. JP Morgan Chase and Bank of America’s AI-powered cash flow forecasting tools have cut human manual work by 90%. David Leary highlighted this incredible statistic: “About 2,500 corporate enterprise clients are now using this tool, and they’ve cut human manual work. So you want to care to guess how much they’ve cut it by? 90%.”

The implications for accounting firms are profound. AI could lead to the end of billable hours and timesheets due to significant productivity gains. As I shared in the podcast, “We are using AI to do the base layer of work, and we are going to then have experts who review that. We’re going to turbocharge our staff.”

These advancements demonstrate how AI can dramatically increase productivity, setting new industry efficiency benchmarks as cloud accounting did.

Embracing AI: The Key to Success

Despite the potential of AI, the accounting industry appears hesitant to embrace this technology fully. Despite high awareness, an Accounting Today survey revealed that only 19% of accountants have used AI tools like ChatGPT for work and personal reasons. This hesitancy could put firms at a competitive disadvantage.

And even if they overcome their hesitancy, overwork impedes AI adoption in traditional firms. As I mentioned in the podcast, “The firms that are overloading their people, they’re not going to be able to innovate in this way because it takes a lot of time.” 

The Future of Accounting in the AI Era

AI, like cloud accounting before it, is set to revolutionize the accounting industry by redefining benchmarks for productivity and success. However, the industry’s hesitancy to embrace AI could hinder firms from realizing its full potential. Accounting firms that proactively invest in AI automation and adapt their business models will be better positioned to succeed in the AI era. At the same time, those who resist change may struggle to keep up. 

The future of accounting is here, and AI powers it. Are you ready? To learn more about how AI is transforming the accounting industry and what your firm can do to stay ahead, listen to the full episode of The Accounting Podcast. Don’t miss out on this insightful and thought-provoking discussion!

The Eroding Trust in Audits: Confronting a Crisis of Confidence

· ·

In a stunning courtroom moment, auditing giant BDO argued that its own audit opinions were too generic to be relied upon by investors. This shocking admission underscores a disturbing trend: the rapid erosion of trust in the value of audits.

In this eye-opening episode of The Accounting Podcast, we sit down with accounting professor Ed Ketz to confront the harsh realities facing the auditing profession amidst a crisis of confidence. How have the limitations of audit opinions, the pass/fail nature of audits, and high-profile failures contributed to this erosion of trust? What does the alarmingly high rate of audit deficiencies reveal about the state of the profession? Can the value of audits be restored, or are we facing a fundamental reckoning?

The Limitations of Audit Opinions

At the heart of the trust crisis lies a troubling question: How much value do audit opinions provide investors? In the AmTrust case, BDO made a jaw-dropping argument that strikes at the core of the audit’s purpose. As Prof. Ketz explains:

“Essentially, they said that the audit opinion is just too general. It cannot be refined or dug down into very far, and therefore, it really couldn’t have value. Therefore, they wanted the case dismissed. They said it was not actionable because it didn’t say anything, which is an incredible statement for an accounting firm. They’re basically trying to talk themselves out of a business.”

This stunning admission from an audit firm raises doubts about the usefulness of opinions in their current form. If the auditors themselves disclaim the value of their work, how can investors be expected to rely on it?

The Pass/Fail Problem

The binary pass/fail system of audits has also come under scrutiny as a contributing factor to the erosion of trust. As I pointed out: “When we have this pass/fail system where the bar is seemingly very, very low, and very few companies ever actually fail an audit, we have this system that just doesn’t create much value anymore for investors. If we want the audit to have value and the CPA to be valuable, maybe we should consider changing how we do business to create value for investors.”

The low bar for receiving an unqualified or “pass” opinion fails to provide meaningful information to investors. A more nuanced and informative reporting model is needed for audits to regain trust.

However, Prof. Ketz argues that despite the limitations of the pass/fail model, research suggests audits still provide valuable signals to the market. Studies have found that going concern opinions offer predictive power above and beyond financial ratios alone. UK firms that continued to be audited even when no longer required enjoyed higher credit ratings. So, while the current system is flawed, Ketz cautions against dismissing the value of audits entirely.

Rampant Deficiencies

Compounding the crisis of confidence is the staggering rate of audit deficiencies revealed by regulatory inspections. The PCAOB’s findings of deficiencies in over 40% of audits inspected in 2022 paint a disturbing picture of a profession struggling to uphold basic standards, further eroding public trust.

Can investors trust any audit opinions if 40% of audits are so deficient that they shouldn’t have been relied upon? These findings underscore the need for the profession to get its house in order if it hopes to restore confidence.

High-Profile Failures

Nothing has done more damage to the credibility of audits than the litany of high-profile failures in recent years. From Wirecard to Tingo to Colonial Bank, each scandal has chipped away at public confidence, raising doubts about auditors’ ability to fulfill their essential role.

The Colonial Bank case, in particular, stands out as a damning indictment. As Prof. Ketz notes:

“In that case, PwC was sued by the FDIC, and the FDIC refused to settle the case. Reading Barbara Rothstein, the judge’s opinion, you can see her chastisement. But more to the point, you can understand the over $600 million judgment she levied against PwC.”

Prof. Ketz notes that in addition to regulatory penalties, the tort system plays a vital role in holding auditors accountable. He points to the Colonial Bank case, where PwC faced a $600 million judgment, as evidence that the threat of costly lawsuits can be a powerful deterrent against shoddy audits.

However, such massive failures and the lack of detailed information in audit reports that could help investors understand what went wrong have still affected the profession’s standing.

A Case for Value?

Amid the crisis, it’s crucial to examine the evidence that audits, despite their flaws, still provide value to investors. Research shows that audit opinions improve the prediction of business failures, and data on higher credit ratings for audited UK firms suggest audits aren’t entirely without merit.

However, while this research shouldn’t be ignored, it can’t erase the deep scars on credibility left by failures and deficiencies. While not baseless, the case for audit value faces an uphill battle in the current climate.

Confronting Hard Truths

The erosion of audit trust is not a hypothetical concern – it’s a full-blown crisis threatening the profession’s foundation. Limitations of opinions, binary results, rampant deficiencies, and high-profile failures have all taken a staggering toll.

Rebuilding this lost trust will require a fundamental rethinking of audits conducted and communicated. Band-aid solutions won’t suffice in the face of such deep-rooted problems. The profession must confront hard truths, embrace bold reforms, or risk irrelevance.

This is a conversation the accounting world can’t afford to ignore. Tune in to the full episode to hear more of Prof. Ketz’s insights and join us in grappling with these critical challenges. The future of auditing hangs in the balance.

Navigating the Crossroads: How the Accounting Profession Can Thrive in a Rapidly Evolving Landscape

· ·

The accounting profession is at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges and opportunities in a world that’s changing faster than ever. As co-host of The Accounting Podcast, I’ve been diving deep into the pressing issues confronting our profession, and it’s clear that we need to embrace innovation and adaptation to stay relevant and thrive in the face of change.

In episode 376, my co-host David Leary and I tackled two issues related to these challenges: The 150-hour rule and billable hours. Here’s a summary of our discussion. For more, I encourage you to listen to the full episode.

Challenging the Status Quo: The Debate Over CPA Licensure Requirements

One of the most heated debates in our profession right now is around the 150-hour CPA licensure requirement. In Minnesota, there’s a proposed legislation to create an alternative pathway to the CPA license, requiring 120 credit hours and two years of experience instead. This challenges the long-standing 150-hour rule and has sparked a lot of discussion in the accounting community.

Jen Leary, CEO of CliftonLarsonAllen LLP, testified in support of this change, saying, “There are multiple studies that show that the 150-hour requirement has created barriers for students, especially minority students, to becoming CPAs. There is no evidence that the 150-hour requirement has improved the quality of the profession. We have the power to change this.”

If this legislation passes, it could inspire other states to explore innovative solutions to the challenges facing the CPA pipeline. It highlights the importance of reevaluating traditional models of education and credentialing to ensure they remain relevant, accessible, and equitable in a changing world.

Beyond Billable Hours: Reimagining the Business of Accounting

Another hot topic in our profession is the billable hour business model. It’s been a staple of the accounting profession for decades, but it’s increasingly scrutinized for its impact on employee well-being and work-life balance. 

As I’ve argued passionately on the podcast, “It all comes down to the billable hour. Treating people like machines that churn out hours like widgets. The firm is built to overwork you, to get as much as possible out of you like you are a machine.” If we want to address the cultural issues in our profession, we need to explore alternative business models that prioritize employee well-being and work-life balance.

Embracing Change: The Way Forward for the Accounting Profession

From rethinking CPA licensure requirements to reimagining the business of accounting firms, the profession faces significant challenges and opportunities in the years ahead. As societal expectations around diversity, inclusion, and work-life balance continue to evolve, the profession must be willing to question long-standing assumptions, explore innovative solutions, and chart a new course forward.

To dive deeper into these critical issues and join the conversation about the future of the accounting profession, be sure to listen to the full episode of The Accounting Podcast.