Earmark CPE

Earn CPE Anytime, Anywhere

Podcasts

The Eroding Trust in Audits: Confronting a Crisis of Confidence

· ·

In a stunning courtroom moment, auditing giant BDO argued that its own audit opinions were too generic to be relied upon by investors. This shocking admission underscores a disturbing trend: the rapid erosion of trust in the value of audits.

In this eye-opening episode of The Accounting Podcast, we sit down with accounting professor Ed Ketz to confront the harsh realities facing the auditing profession amidst a crisis of confidence. How have the limitations of audit opinions, the pass/fail nature of audits, and high-profile failures contributed to this erosion of trust? What does the alarmingly high rate of audit deficiencies reveal about the state of the profession? Can the value of audits be restored, or are we facing a fundamental reckoning?

The Limitations of Audit Opinions

At the heart of the trust crisis lies a troubling question: How much value do audit opinions provide investors? In the AmTrust case, BDO made a jaw-dropping argument that strikes at the core of the audit’s purpose. As Prof. Ketz explains:

“Essentially, they said that the audit opinion is just too general. It cannot be refined or dug down into very far, and therefore, it really couldn’t have value. Therefore, they wanted the case dismissed. They said it was not actionable because it didn’t say anything, which is an incredible statement for an accounting firm. They’re basically trying to talk themselves out of a business.”

This stunning admission from an audit firm raises doubts about the usefulness of opinions in their current form. If the auditors themselves disclaim the value of their work, how can investors be expected to rely on it?

The Pass/Fail Problem

The binary pass/fail system of audits has also come under scrutiny as a contributing factor to the erosion of trust. As I pointed out: “When we have this pass/fail system where the bar is seemingly very, very low, and very few companies ever actually fail an audit, we have this system that just doesn’t create much value anymore for investors. If we want the audit to have value and the CPA to be valuable, maybe we should consider changing how we do business to create value for investors.”

The low bar for receiving an unqualified or “pass” opinion fails to provide meaningful information to investors. A more nuanced and informative reporting model is needed for audits to regain trust.

However, Prof. Ketz argues that despite the limitations of the pass/fail model, research suggests audits still provide valuable signals to the market. Studies have found that going concern opinions offer predictive power above and beyond financial ratios alone. UK firms that continued to be audited even when no longer required enjoyed higher credit ratings. So, while the current system is flawed, Ketz cautions against dismissing the value of audits entirely.

Rampant Deficiencies

Compounding the crisis of confidence is the staggering rate of audit deficiencies revealed by regulatory inspections. The PCAOB’s findings of deficiencies in over 40% of audits inspected in 2022 paint a disturbing picture of a profession struggling to uphold basic standards, further eroding public trust.

Can investors trust any audit opinions if 40% of audits are so deficient that they shouldn’t have been relied upon? These findings underscore the need for the profession to get its house in order if it hopes to restore confidence.

High-Profile Failures

Nothing has done more damage to the credibility of audits than the litany of high-profile failures in recent years. From Wirecard to Tingo to Colonial Bank, each scandal has chipped away at public confidence, raising doubts about auditors’ ability to fulfill their essential role.

The Colonial Bank case, in particular, stands out as a damning indictment. As Prof. Ketz notes:

“In that case, PwC was sued by the FDIC, and the FDIC refused to settle the case. Reading Barbara Rothstein, the judge’s opinion, you can see her chastisement. But more to the point, you can understand the over $600 million judgment she levied against PwC.”

Prof. Ketz notes that in addition to regulatory penalties, the tort system plays a vital role in holding auditors accountable. He points to the Colonial Bank case, where PwC faced a $600 million judgment, as evidence that the threat of costly lawsuits can be a powerful deterrent against shoddy audits.

However, such massive failures and the lack of detailed information in audit reports that could help investors understand what went wrong have still affected the profession’s standing.

A Case for Value?

Amid the crisis, it’s crucial to examine the evidence that audits, despite their flaws, still provide value to investors. Research shows that audit opinions improve the prediction of business failures, and data on higher credit ratings for audited UK firms suggest audits aren’t entirely without merit.

However, while this research shouldn’t be ignored, it can’t erase the deep scars on credibility left by failures and deficiencies. While not baseless, the case for audit value faces an uphill battle in the current climate.

Confronting Hard Truths

The erosion of audit trust is not a hypothetical concern – it’s a full-blown crisis threatening the profession’s foundation. Limitations of opinions, binary results, rampant deficiencies, and high-profile failures have all taken a staggering toll.

Rebuilding this lost trust will require a fundamental rethinking of audits conducted and communicated. Band-aid solutions won’t suffice in the face of such deep-rooted problems. The profession must confront hard truths, embrace bold reforms, or risk irrelevance.

This is a conversation the accounting world can’t afford to ignore. Tune in to the full episode to hear more of Prof. Ketz’s insights and join us in grappling with these critical challenges. The future of auditing hangs in the balance.

The Resilient Entrepreneur: Strategies for Embracing Uncertainty in Your Small Business

· ·

In the ever-changing landscape of entrepreneurship, uncertainty is the only constant. As a small business owner, how can you survive and thrive in the face of unpredictable challenges? In a recent episode of “Build to Enough,” host Keila Hill-Trawick dives deep into the strategies and mindsets necessary for navigating uncertainty as a small business owner. From her accountant expertise and experience working with diverse clients, Keila shares invaluable insights on proactive preparation, adaptation, and leveraging external support.

The Importance of Proactive Financial Preparation

Small businesses face a myriad of uncertainties, each with its unique challenges. As Keila points out, “When we’re talking about uncertainty for small businesses, it can mean a variety of things, from economic downturns or changes in the economy that affect both you as a small business owner or your particular industry, to market volatility and other external factors like local changes or a pandemic.” Recognizing and anticipating these various types of uncertainty is the first step in developing a resilient business strategy.

One critical component of navigating uncertainty is proactive financial preparation. Keila emphasizes the importance of maintaining a 3-6 month expense cushion and accurate bookkeeping. “You want to make sure that you have a savings account that will cover you when and if there are any changes to your business income.” By taking these proactive measures, small business owners can create a financial safety net that allows them to weather unexpected challenges and maintain stability during times of uncertainty.

Strategic Adaptation: Staying Agile in the Face of Change

In addition to financial preparation, strategic adaptation is critical to building resilience as a small business owner. Keila stresses the importance of periodically reassessing services, target clients, and pricing to ensure value provision and adaptability:

“When we get into business, it can be easy to think we can set it and forget it… But the landscape is constantly changing,” Keila advises. “The ideas about what is good, right, and valuable for the people we serve are constantly in flux, and we can’t always keep up with all those changes. But what we can do is make a commitment to say at various points throughout the year, ‘I will check in and make sure that one, what I’m doing is what I want to be doing; two, that I’m serving the right clients within those services; and three, that I am pricing myself in a way that reflects the value that I am providing.’”

Keila shares an example of clients in the diversity and inclusion training industry who had to pivot when corporate priorities shifted. She explains that when D&I was a booming area, many of her clients in that industry were making significant profits. Corporations were investing in D&I initiatives and hiring trainers at competitive rates to come in and work with their companies.

However, this trend did not continue indefinitely. Keila notes that, perhaps unsurprisingly, many companies eventually slashed their D&I budgets or decided it was no longer a top priority. As a result, D&I trainers who had previously been thriving in this space would have lost money if they had not adapted their strategies.

This example highlights the importance of strategic adaptation in the face of changing market conditions and client priorities. It demonstrates how small businesses and entrepreneurs must remain agile and responsive to shifts in demand, even in areas that were once highly profitable. Small business owners can increase their resilience and ability to navigate uncertainty in their respective industries by being prepared to pivot their offerings or target new markets when necessary.

Leveraging External Support and Expertise

Navigating uncertainty doesn’t have to be a solo journey. Keila emphasizes seeking guidance from industry professionals, peers, and mentors when facing unpredictable challenges. She says, “Finding experts that know more than you, or just have access to resources that you might not have access to, is really a good way to prepare yourself against those uncertain times that are going to show up for you.”

Moreover, being part of a supportive community where members can offer mutual support during challenging times can be invaluable. Small business owners can gain new perspectives, insights, and strategies for navigating uncertainty by tapping into collective wisdom and resources.

Embracing Uncertainty as a Natural Part of Business

Ultimately, uncertainty is an inevitable part of the entrepreneurial journey. As Keila reminds us, “At the end of the day, uncertainty is a natural part of business. None of us know what’s going to happen, and our best-laid plans go to crap all the time because you just don’t know what’s going to happen around you.” 

Rather than avoiding uncertainty altogether, small business owners must embrace it as a natural part of the process and focus on developing the resilience and adaptability necessary to thrive in the face of change.

Tune in to “Build to Enough” to Learn More

Navigating uncertainty as a small business owner requires a multifaceted approach that includes proactive preparation, strategic adaptation, and leveraging external support. By developing financial stability, staying agile in the face of change, and tapping into the wisdom and resources of a supportive community, entrepreneurs can build the resilience necessary to survive and thrive in unpredictable challenges.

Tune in to this episode of “Build to Enough” to learn more about navigating uncertainty as a small business owner and discover practical strategies for proactive preparation, adaptation, and leveraging external support. With the right mindset and tools, you can build a meaningful and sustainable business that weathers any storm.

Navigating the Crossroads: How the Accounting Profession Can Thrive in a Rapidly Evolving Landscape

· ·

The accounting profession is at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges and opportunities in a world that’s changing faster than ever. As co-host of The Accounting Podcast, I’ve been diving deep into the pressing issues confronting our profession, and it’s clear that we need to embrace innovation and adaptation to stay relevant and thrive in the face of change.

In episode 376, my co-host David Leary and I tackled two issues related to these challenges: The 150-hour rule and billable hours. Here’s a summary of our discussion. For more, I encourage you to listen to the full episode.

Challenging the Status Quo: The Debate Over CPA Licensure Requirements

One of the most heated debates in our profession right now is around the 150-hour CPA licensure requirement. In Minnesota, there’s a proposed legislation to create an alternative pathway to the CPA license, requiring 120 credit hours and two years of experience instead. This challenges the long-standing 150-hour rule and has sparked a lot of discussion in the accounting community.

Jen Leary, CEO of CliftonLarsonAllen LLP, testified in support of this change, saying, “There are multiple studies that show that the 150-hour requirement has created barriers for students, especially minority students, to becoming CPAs. There is no evidence that the 150-hour requirement has improved the quality of the profession. We have the power to change this.”

If this legislation passes, it could inspire other states to explore innovative solutions to the challenges facing the CPA pipeline. It highlights the importance of reevaluating traditional models of education and credentialing to ensure they remain relevant, accessible, and equitable in a changing world.

Beyond Billable Hours: Reimagining the Business of Accounting

Another hot topic in our profession is the billable hour business model. It’s been a staple of the accounting profession for decades, but it’s increasingly scrutinized for its impact on employee well-being and work-life balance. 

As I’ve argued passionately on the podcast, “It all comes down to the billable hour. Treating people like machines that churn out hours like widgets. The firm is built to overwork you, to get as much as possible out of you like you are a machine.” If we want to address the cultural issues in our profession, we need to explore alternative business models that prioritize employee well-being and work-life balance.

Embracing Change: The Way Forward for the Accounting Profession

From rethinking CPA licensure requirements to reimagining the business of accounting firms, the profession faces significant challenges and opportunities in the years ahead. As societal expectations around diversity, inclusion, and work-life balance continue to evolve, the profession must be willing to question long-standing assumptions, explore innovative solutions, and chart a new course forward.

To dive deeper into these critical issues and join the conversation about the future of the accounting profession, be sure to listen to the full episode of The Accounting Podcast.

The Whistleblower’s Dilemma: Exposing the Truth in the Face of Adversity

· ·

Whistleblowers play a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of financial markets. By exposing fraudulent practices and other misconduct, these brave individuals help protect investors, employees, and the public from the devastating consequences of corporate wrongdoing. However, as recent high-profile cases have shown, whistleblowers often face significant challenges and obstacles in their pursuit of justice.

One such case is that of Tony Menendez, a former employee of Halliburton who blew the whistle on the company’s improper revenue recognition practices. In a recent episode of the “Oh My Fraud” podcast, Menendez shared his experience and the lessons he learned from his ordeal.

High-profile whistleblower cases like Menendez’s reveal common challenges faced by those who speak out against wrongdoing in the accounting industry. These cases emphasize the need for stronger protections and more effective enforcement of existing laws to maintain public trust and ensure market integrity.

Notable Whistleblower Cases in the Accounting Industry

Menendez’s story began in 2005 when he joined Halliburton as a technical accounting expert. He soon discovered that the company was using “bill and hold” transactions to recognize revenue prematurely. Despite raising concerns with his superiors, Menendez was met with resistance and was told to stop looking into the issue.

“I drafted a memo saying, ‘Here’s what we’re doing, and this is what we should be doing.’ We spent months because we had to get this right,” Menendez recalled. “At this time, I also established a relationship with the auditor on the account, and I brought it to his attention. He’s like, ‘Yeah, this is a big freaking deal. This is how they recognize revenue all across the globe.'”

Menendez’s experience is not unique. Other high-profile whistleblower cases in the accounting industry, such as the Enron scandal and the WorldCom scandal, have exposed similar patterns of misconduct and retaliation against those who spoke out.

In the Enron case, Sherron Watkins, a vice president at the company, warned CEO Kenneth Lay about accounting irregularities. In the WorldCom case, internal auditor Cynthia Cooper uncovered billions of dollars in fraudulent accounting entries.

These cases had a profound impact on public perception of the accounting profession, eroding trust in the industry and increasing skepticism towards financial reporting.

Common Obstacles Faced by Whistleblowers

Whistleblowers in the accounting industry often face significant obstacles, including retaliation from their employers. In Menendez’s case, he experienced isolation and loss of job responsibilities after raising concerns about Halliburton’s accounting practices.

“My job was working with the auditors every day. That was my job and everybody else’s,” Menendez said. “All of a sudden, the auditors basically flat out told the company they would not communicate with me in any way. They would not attend any meetings if I was going to be in the meeting.”

The fear of losing one’s job or facing legal action is a common deterrent for potential whistleblowers. Additionally, a lack of support from regulatory bodies can make it even more challenging for whistleblowers to come forward.

In Menendez’s case, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) failed to investigate his claims against Halliburton thoroughly. “The SEC just abdicated the responsibility,” Menendez said. “They didn’t do an investigation. They just turned around and said, ‘Hey, Halliburton, investigate yourself.'”

The role of political influence in deterring proper investigations cannot be overlooked. As Menendez’s attorney told him, “As long as Dick Cheney’s the vice president of the United States, there’s no way in hell they’re going to touch this case.”

Whistleblowing can also take a significant emotional and personal toll. The stress and anxiety of speaking out against one’s employer can impact personal relationships and mental health.

The Importance of Maintaining Market Integrity 

Maintaining market integrity is essential for the health of the global economy. Accurate financial reporting is crucial for maintaining investor confidence, and CPAs play a vital role in upholding ethical standards and reporting wrongdoing.

The consequences of failing to address improper accounting practices can be severe, including potential widespread economic damage and further erosion of public trust in the accounting profession.

Proposed Solutions to Improve Whistleblower Protections

Several solutions have been proposed to address the challenges faced by whistleblowers in the accounting industry. These include strengthening legal protections for whistleblowers, such as enhancing provisions of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and increasing penalties for companies that retaliate against whistleblowers.

Improving enforcement of existing laws is also critical. This can be achieved by encouraging proactive investigations by regulatory bodies and allocating more resources to the SEC for whistleblower investigations.

Creating a supportive culture within the accounting profession is another key component of protecting whistleblowers. This involves encouraging open communication and reporting of unethical behavior, as well as providing resources and support for whistleblowers within the industry.

For More, Listen to Oh My Fraud

Whistleblowers play a crucial role in maintaining market integrity, but they often face significant challenges and obstacles. High-profile cases like Tony Menendez’s experience at Halliburton reveal the common challenges faced by whistleblowers in the accounting industry and emphasize the need for stronger protections and more effective enforcement of laws.

As CPAs, we are responsible for advocating for whistleblower protection within our organizations and supporting industry-wide efforts to improve whistleblower laws and regulations.

To learn more about Tony Menendez’s experience and the lessons it holds for the accounting profession, I encourage you to listen to the full “Oh My Fraud” podcast episode. His story serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of speaking out against wrongdoing and the need for robust whistleblower protections in our industry.

The Team of Three: How DBA’s Unique Structure Weathered an Unexpected Resignation

· ·

Imagine receiving an email from a team member resigning effective immediately. How would your business cope with such an unexpected challenge?

In a recent episode of “Who’s Really the Boss,” Rachel and Marcus Dillon, the owners of DBA, a leading accounting firm, shared their experience of dealing with a team member’s abrupt resignation and the lessons they learned about building a resilient and adaptable team structure.

The Unexpected Resignation

Rachel and Marcus were caught off guard when they received an email from a team member resigning effective immediately, a first in DBA’s 13-year history.

“Any time you get a notice, like resigning effective immediately, you need to think, ‘Okay, something extreme has happened.’ And as a leader, can you do anything to help?” Rachel recalled.

This experience highlighted the importance of having a team structure that can handle unexpected turnover and the need for clear communication and swift action in such situations.

DBA’s Team of Three Model

One of the key factors that helped DBA navigate this challenge was its unique team structure, consisting of a Client Service Manager, Client Controller, and Client CFO.

Marcus explained, “So with that team of three model, there is always overlap. And that’s why we designed it that way. It’s very unlikely that all three people would leave the team at one time. If two people leave the team at one time, that’s drastic.” This model provides built-in redundancy and ensures smooth service delivery, even in the face of unexpected turnover.

The team of three model allowed DBA to redistribute responsibilities and maintain uninterrupted client service quickly. The Client Controller and Client CFO stepped up to initially cover the departing team member’s duties while the company searched for a replacement. This seamless transition demonstrated the resilience and adaptability of DBA’s team structure.

Capacity Planning and Lessons Learned

Proper capacity planning is another crucial aspect of building a resilient and adaptable team. Rachel and Marcus emphasized the importance of maintaining excess capacity to handle unexpected situations and opportunities.

“We’ve learned it the hard way. Whenever you burn out team members – and thankfully, some of those team members that burned out, they’ve stayed on the team. We’ve restructured their role. We restructured their client list to make it more appropriate for balance,” Marcus shared.

Overworking team members can lead to burnout and turnover, undermining the team’s resilience and adaptability. DBA learned this lesson and made conscious efforts to ensure their team members have a healthy work-life balance. They have removed blocks of annual tax clients and avoided filling up the team’s capacity with seasonal work, prioritizing long-term sustainability over short-term profits.

Navigating the Transition

When faced with the unexpected resignation, DBA took immediate action to ensure a smooth transition. They notified the leadership team, reassigned clients and responsibilities, and communicated with affected clients. The company’s well-defined offboarding and onboarding processes were crucial in navigating this challenge.

DBA’s offboarding process involved disconnecting the departing team member’s access to various systems, reassigning email and communication channels, and ensuring a seamless transition for clients. The company’s onboarding process, which includes training new team members on client-specific information and gradually introducing them to clients, allowed for a smooth integration of the replacement team member.

Having a pipeline of candidates and a structured hiring process also contributed to DBA’s ability to fill the vacancy quickly. Within two weeks of the resignation, the company had identified and onboarded a new Client Service Manager, minimizing disruption to client service.

The Importance of a Resilient and Adaptable Team

DBA’s experience highlights the importance of building a resilient and adaptable team structure in today’s fast-paced business environment. Handling unexpected challenges, such as a team member’s abrupt resignation, is crucial for maintaining client trust and ensuring long-term success and sustainability.

A well-designed team model, like DBA’s team of three, provides built-in redundancy and ensures smooth service delivery. Proper capacity planning and a focus on employee well-being contribute to the team’s resilience and adaptability. Well-defined processes for handling transitions, both offboarding and onboarding, allow businesses to navigate challenges smoothly and maintain client confidence.

Building a resilient and adaptable team requires a proactive approach and a commitment to continuous improvement. By learning from experiences like DBA’s unexpected turnover challenge, business owners can develop strategies to strengthen their teams and prepare for the unexpected.

Listen to the full episode of “Who’s Really the Boss” to learn more about how Rachel and Marcus Dillon, with the help of their team, navigated this challenge and the valuable lessons they learned along the way.