• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Earmark CPE

Earmark CPE

Earn CPE Anytime, Anywhere

  • Home
  • App
    • Pricing
    • Web App
    • Download iOS
    • Download Android
    • Release Notes
  • Webinars
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Authors
  • Sponsors
  • About
    • Press
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Earmark Podcast

How the Autonomous Close Changes Who Gets Paid in an Accounting Firm

Earmark Team · November 12, 2026 ·

“The target is $1 million in client fees per accountant,” Blake Oliver says, opening Episode 119 of the Earmark Podcast. Then he asks: if software runs the close and accountants handle the review, that efficiency is worth serious money. So who gets it? The firm, the client or you?

His guest, Jessica McKellar, studied computer science at MIT, co-founded Pilot as CTO and now runs it as CEO. Pilot is a bookkeeping, tax prep and CFO advisory firm. It closed nine years of books, roughly 187,000 month-end closes, before it started selling its Meridian software to other firms. Pilot sponsored the episode.

Pilot uses autonomous closes in pursuit of an internal goal of $1 million in client revenue per accountant. Jessica expects if production work can be done in software, it often will be. The opportunity left is judgment, review and client relationships, a shift software engineers have already lived through. On the episode, they discuss how the autonomous close works, Blake’s pushback, and the engineering parallel.

Taking the Accountant Out of the Iron Man Suit

The revenue goal depends on one shift. Software has to stop helping accountants close the books and start running the close itself, all the way through to review.

Pilot didn’t start there. In 2016, Jessica’s co-founder clicked around QuickBooks Online while she hovered over his shoulder, writing the first version of the software against the QuickBooks Online APIs. The first-generation tools were “the Iron Man suit for accountants.” They were effective, but the experience involved constant “context switching or handoffs between a person and the software.” With that kind of workflow augmentation, she says, moving firm-level metrics can be “surprisingly difficult.”

Over the last 18 months or so, foundation models advanced to the point where “you can actually take the accountant out of the Iron Man suit” and put an AI agent in it. As long as the data inputs are in place, she says, the close runs on its own through to review. Once firms get comfortable, the close kicks off at the start of the month and “you wake up to completed books.”

For Jessica, the payoff is predictability. “It reduces the work, but it reduces the variance.” That means fewer capacity mismatches and fewer Sundays spent covering for a sick colleague.

Blake’s Skepticism, Tested

In Blake’s view, blockers, accuracy and the audit trail stand in the way.

“I’ve always been skeptical of the claims of fully autonomous month-end close,” he says. In his experience, missing client information comes up in almost every task.

Jessica separates true blockers, like no access to the primary checking account, from judgment calls. Her example is a client paying Gusto for the first time when Meridian has no payroll access. The agent parks the activity “somewhere reasonable” and flags it for the reviewer. It can’t do the granular breakout until it gets payroll access or someone uploads a payroll journal. The reviewer then decides whether the issue should hold up the close.

On accuracy, Blake is blunt: “90-something percent is often not enough. It needs to be 100%.” Jessica says the math isn’t left to the AI. “There’s like deterministic software that is doing the math of rolling forward the supporting schedules.” The agent verifies everything ties out, and it flags a broken recon. A full audit log shows why each transaction was categorized, along with monthly cuts of the recons and schedules.

There are still rough edges. Xero doesn’t expose bank reconciliation through its API, so bank feed matching has to happen in a browser.

Software Engineers Already Lived This

Jessica’s engineering background gives her prediction weight. “This is the biggest change to software engineering as a profession probably ever,” she says. The old way of “artisanally crafting and reviewing and deploying code” is going away quickly, and many engineers are “in mourning” for skills they spent careers building.

What replaces it? “It’s not about producing the code anymore. It’s about having good taste, good judgment, knowing what to build.” Some engineers find that exciting. For others, it’s “a source of deep existential stress.”

She draws the accounting parallel without softening it. “If that work can be done in software, it’s often going to be.” The judgment, strategy and client work left behind is a real opportunity, but “it’s not going to be for everyone.”

Blake describes the split he already sees. People with judgment and experience become dramatically more productive. He puts himself at “10X.” People without that judgment risk having their jobs automated away. He also points out that this seems to be the first technological revolution to really hit white-collar workers, after earlier ones automated blue-collar jobs.

Who Actually Gets Paid?

Jessica believes “accountants are going to start making more than software engineers in some cases.” Her claim comes with a condition, though, “if some of that efficiency is getting accrued back from a compensation perspective.” She notes that the margin firms reclaim can go to the client experience, to employees or simply back to the firm.

Blake sees the clearest path in the firm of one. “If I can generate a million in revenue and not have to hire anyone,” that solo practitioner would out-earn nearly every engineer outside companies like OpenAI, Anthropic and Meta.

What lasts is human work. Jessica points to “the part that’s being a therapist for your clients,” and to accountability. Clients want to talk to a human when something goes wrong. Work that requires a license or credential stays too.

Blake adds an observation of his own. Accounting ranks near the top of automatability charts, yet new-grad hiring is “totally flat” while other professions are down 10% to 20%. He wonders whether that reflects slack from the talent shortage or something the analyses miss. Jessica’s answer is the durable relationship between business owners and an expert they can rely on.

The $1 Million Accountant Is a Role, Not a Gift

Software may make the $1 million number possible. It doesn’t hand it to anyone. Getting there means moving toward review, judgment and client relationships as more production work shifts to software.

“It’s never been a better time, to my mind, to be an accountant,” Jessica says, but also, “I’m not exactly sure what’s going to be happening for us all five years from now.”

Firm owners and staff need to consider how they’ll share the efficiency gains. Listen to the full episode for Jessica’s walkthrough of the autonomous close and her conversation with Blake about AI’s effect on the profession.

What Happens to Your Accounting Firm After AI Takes Over Payroll?

Earmark Team · November 10, 2026 ·

“AI creates capacity, but it does not create demand.” That’s how Echo Zhong, CPA, opens this episode of the Earmark Podcast, and it runs counter to Gusto’s pitch to let software handle payroll so your firm gets its hours back for advisory. Echo sees what happens after the hours come back. Gusto sponsored this episode.

Blake Oliver sat down with Echo at Gusto Next, right after her live demo of Gusto’s new multi-client MCP. She’s been a CPA for more than 15 years and runs Zhong & Sanchez, a full-service boutique firm in Cupertino. It’s across the street from Y Combinator and serves bootstrapped small business owners and VC-backed startups, including many YC companies. By her estimate, her automated workflow saves at least 80% of the time on routine payroll and forecasting updates. But she argues the freed hours don’t fill themselves. Firms have to find the demand, redeploy their people, and win on trust.

Below, we cover what the automation does, where billing goes next, what happened to her payroll manager, and the threat from AI-native startups.

What “AI runs payroll” looks like

This isn’t vaporware. Echo built a scheduled task in Claude that scans the firm’s inboxes and works out which clients sent in hours. It flags anyone who hasn’t, catches new hires who need to be entered, and flags approaching deadlines without the needed info. Then it queues up payroll for approval, which her team can grant in Claude or in Gusto, depending on their comfort level.

The workflow doesn’t stop at payroll. Her team downloads the payroll journal in Excel, and Claude uses it to update the client’s cash flow forecast. For her demo client, that’s a 13-month forecast. The client hired someone new on the same pay and schedule as an existing employee. Claude updated the forecast and called out the new assumptions for review. It doesn’t matter who at the firm runs it, Echo says. “It will just deliver consistent results.”

She’d like to think the workflow saves at least 80% of the time on these updates. A simple update used to take 20 to 30 minutes, longer if someone lost the forwarded email. Scenario analysis could take hours.

The multi-client piece raises the stakes. Blake describes MCPs as the way apps talk to each other. Echo says most MCPs on the market don’t support multiple clients, so each client needs its own connection. With Gusto, one connection covers every client she has access to. “If I’m running payroll for 50 clients… I can just run it one time.” Echo calls it “a pretty big game changer.”

Stop billing for filings, start billing for ownership

Blake pushed further. Gusto also handles state registrations, registered agent services, and annual reports. “This is all work that accounting firms have charged for in the past.”

Echo used to do state registrations manually about ten years ago. Now she points clients to Gusto. But clients still want “a point of contact who’s just owning the job of state registration, state nexus and things like that.” Dealing with the government is still a pain, and her entrepreneurs are “optimizing for peace of mind.” They’d rather offload compliance and not think about it.

So what does she charge for? For startups, her firm acts as a fractional CFO, and the cash flow forecast is “usually just the start of a conversation.” It leads to retirement and exit planning, lending or fundraising for liquidity, and resourcing an expansion. Clients come to her, she says, because they want “a trusted advisor” for the long term, not “a technology solution that’s only probably solving one of your problems.”

Blake wasn’t fully convinced. Charging for advisory “is difficult, at least for a lot of accountants,” he said. Echo’s pricing rule is simple. “If we’re owning the job, then I’m charging for it.” If a client would rather handle it in Gusto themselves, the firm hands over the tools and instructions so they can self-serve.

The payroll manager problem is a change-management problem

None of that happens if the people doing the old work stay stuck in it. “If I were a payroll manager right now,” Blake admitted, “I would be a little worried.”

Echo’s payroll manager was. She was anxious at first and pushed back on the move to Gusto. Echo reframed the conversation. “We’re not trying to get rid of your job, but hey, do you even enjoy doing data entry?” Then she asked where the manager saw herself in three to five years. Once it was clear nobody was being fired, the shift happened “more naturally.” The manager moved into tax advisory work.

Echo is candid that it doesn’t always go this smoothly. It depends on the person and on the trust between owner and staff. Some firms, she suggests, might find it helpful to bring in a change management consultant.

Blake sees a mindset shift underneath all this. In his twenties, the key skill was mastering interfaces like desktop QuickBooks. Now “the hard part is actually imagining a different way of doing the process.”

Echo added a caveat. Firms and software companies still need to work together on the ability to audit results and “the chain of events” behind them.

When startups sell the work, not the tool

The bigger threat may come from outside the firm. Blake laid out a theory he’d read that SaaS sold tools to professionals, but the new AI startups are “actually selling the work.” That now includes tax, accounting, and audit, delivered with “10% of the people or less.”

Echo bets that some people want to work with people, while others would rather self-serve. She’ll serve the first group. Her evidence is that conferences are getting bigger and community events keep popping up. People “will trust a person’s recommendation” even when that person uses software behind the scenes.

She’s not anti-AI, either. She compares her token spending against the cost of hiring. When Blake asked if she’d spend tens of thousands of dollars on tokens, she said that would mean “it’s still saving me an army.”

Capacity is cheap; demand is the job

In Echo’s view, AI will keep creating capacity. If your revenue depends on keying hours and filing state forms, that work is already being automated. As she sees it, what’s left for the firm is finding demand, owning outcomes, and earning trust.

Listen to the full episode for Echo’s demo details and Blake’s self-improving email skill, and earn free CPE while you’re at it.

How Finance Leaders Can Tell Whether AI Is Really Paying Off

Earmark Team · October 23, 2026 ·

Your AI bill tells you what you spent, but not whether anything got better.

That divide worries finance leaders. Mike DePrisco, President and CEO of the Institute of Management Accountants (IMA), speaks with hundreds of CFOs and finance leaders around the world. Their questions have evolved from whether to use AI to how to get value from it.

On the Earmark Podcast, Mike and host Blake Oliver, CPA, explored how accountants can measure that value. The challenge is finding business improvements and developing people who can check, interpret, and explain AI’s output.

Adoption isn’t the same as a return

AI is the top concern among the finance leaders Mike meets. They’re deploying and investing in it, but skepticism is growing about the payoff.

“We’re not seeing the promised return on investment fast enough,” he says, describing what he hears from leaders.

Blake points to a related problem: rising costs. He describes a shift from predictable subscriptions of roughly $20 to $100 per seat toward additional usage-based charges from providers like Anthropic and OpenAI. Those charges are measured in tokens, the units used to track model usage, and CFOs and controllers struggle to keep spending under control.

Mike says accounting and finance professionals adopted AI slowly, partly because mistakes can affect financial statements, reporting, and compliance. That caution was reasonable. Now that more organizations use the technology, they need tangible evidence that it works.

But tracking spending is only half the problem. What should leaders measure on the other side?

Measure what actually improves

Blake notes that token costs are measurable. Connecting those costs to outcomes is harder. Mike offers several practical indicators, not as a complete ROI formula, but as ways to judge whether an investment produces value.

  • Finance operations. “Are you closing the books more quickly?” Mike asks. Are you reducing errors month over month? Together, these measures help show whether AI improves speed and quality.
  • Decision support. Is forecasting more accurate? Mike connects better forecasts with better decisions and better use of resources. More output alone doesn’t prove value; the information needs to help the business make decisions.
  • Customer experience. Does the technology address actual customer problems? Internal customers may need to get work done faster or at lower cost. External customers may want smoother transactions or easier searches.

For financial institutions, Mike gives a specific example of reducing false fraud flags that put customers’ accounts on hold. That’s a business outcome, not just an improvement inside the finance department.

Organizations IMA works with are starting to use these measures to decide whether AI is working and whether to continue, scale, or invest more.

Mike suggests the strongest results come from having a clear problem to solve. But even a useful application still needs people who can question its output.

Faster work still needs sound judgment

Blake raises concerns about AI reducing entry-level work in public accounting. Mike isn’t fully convinced that the technology will mean fewer jobs overall. He expects jobs to change, but sees a continuing need for accounting knowledge.

“We see the mistakes that AI makes every single day,” he says. People with business knowledge and customer context spend time correcting those mistakes.

He describes this as human-machine collaboration. People must stay involved to check for bias, verify accuracy, and interpret information before using it to make decisions.

That’s why foundational training is still important. When Mike asks faculty how they respond to machines taking over basic work, they tell him students still need to understand the fundamentals. If students are going to work alongside these machines, “they need to know what to look for.”

The role also extends beyond checking numbers. Mike describes management accountants as business partners who interpret data from AI, ERP systems, and forecasting tools. They help other functions assess opportunities, solve problems, and make decisions.

That creates a training challenge. How do accountants build judgment if technology takes over the routine work where earlier generations learned?

Build the skills AI can’t supply on its own

IMA expanded its competency framework to include advanced data analytics, transformation, innovation, sustainability, and leadership. Mike says employers need strategic thinking, clear communication, and people who ask challenging questions.

Accountants also benefit from storytelling skills, since they need to explain information in the context of the organization’s strategy.

Blake pushes back, noting these sound like mid-level or executive skills. Mike points to internships, stretch assignments, mentorship, and scenario-based training as ways to help younger professionals practice them.

He also describes replacing an essay-based section of the Certified Management Accountant (CMA) exam with case-based questions. The goal is application. “It’s more than just knowing; it’s about doing,” he says. Still, he acknowledges some skills take time and experience to develop.

Blake suggests using AI itself for practice. A learner could describe their role and company to Claude, identify a concept they want to learn, and ask for a guided, simulated challenge.

For mid-career accountants, Mike recommends staying curious and prioritizing learning. He describes IMA’s micro-credentials, including short, focused programs in areas like AI and finance or advanced data analytics. He says professionals can learn something over the weekend and apply it at work on Monday.

Measure the results. Build the judgment.

AI’s value should show up as faster closes, fewer errors, more accurate forecasts, better decisions, and less customer friction. But those results depend on professionals who understand the business and can evaluate what the technology produces.

Listen to Episode 117 of the Earmark Podcast for Blake’s full conversation with Mike.

How Florida CPAs Beat Back a Bill That Would Have Erased Their Own Licensing Board

Earmark Team · July 20, 2026 ·

Shelly Weir stood in the rotunda of the Florida Capitol building. The House floor was on one side, the Senate floor on the other. The clock was ticking toward midnight on the final day of the legislative session. Shelly was physically pulling senators off the floor while CPAs across the state called and texted lawmakers. These were college roommates, siblings, fellow churchgoers, basically anyone with a personal connection to a senior member of the Senate.

Around her, realtors, engineers, and harbor pilots were lined up too, all fighting for their professional lives inside the same 550-page bill. “If there’s one lifeboat,” she recalls thinking, “I’m getting on it. Good luck to you people.”

That was the scene at the end of Florida’s legislative session, and it shows just how close the CPA license came to being dismantled.

On this episode of the Earmark Podcast, host Blake Oliver sits down with Shelly, president and CEO of the Florida Institute of CPAs (FICPA), for her first live interview about a two-year battle most of the profession has never heard about. The legislation she and her team fought would have eliminated Florida’s Board of Accountancy, wiped out continuing education requirements, and paved the way to eliminate licensure education requirements.

FICPA beat it twice.

What’s remarkable is how they won. The strongest defense wasn’t digging in, or what Shelly calls “the agent of no.” It was showing up as the efficiency experts CPAs claim to be. By combining a hard-nosed commerce argument with a genuine willingness to modernize the profession’s outdated rules, FICPA turned an existential threat into an opportunity to reform accounting on its own terms.

The 550-Page Threat That Almost Changed Everything

To understand what FICPA faced, you need to know how Florida makes laws. The state legislature meets for just 60 days a year. As Shelly puts it, “for 60 days, it’s fast and furious. That’s when you get bills passed, or you don’t.”

The warning signs had been there for years. “Anytime you have a piece of legislation that is this significant, there are normally signals it’s coming,” Shelly explained. “There are chess pieces that get put onto the chess board.” She’d been talking to her board and national entities about the threat for years before the bill actually dropped.

When it finally arrived in early April 2025, about halfway through the legislative session, it was a 550-page “behemoth,” in Shelly’s words. Accountants weren’t alone in this fight. The bill included architects, engineers, veterinarians, realtors, and harbor pilots (which, Shelly notes, are “really important in Florida”). The bill bundled them together with a single goal of eliminating their regulatory boards.

For CPAs, that meant three devastating changes. First, the Board of Accountancy would be gone. Second, all continuing education requirements would disappear. Third, it would clear the path toward eliminating licensure education requirements. “Everything we’ve spent the last few years talking about relative to 120- and 150-hours would go away,” Shelly explained. Instead, licenses would be awarded based only on work experience or on passing an exam.

The bundling of professions frustrated Shelly. “Respectfully, hairdressers are not the same thing as a CPA or an engineer.”

FICPA saw two distinct dangers. The immediate threat was breaking Florida’s mobility infrastructure. That’s the system that lets CPAs work seamlessly across state lines. That would cause damage “on day one.” The long-term danger was even worse. The license would either be eliminated or become “so degraded that it carried very little value.”

Why Lawmakers Wanted to Kill Professional Licensing

Shelly’s insight is crucial for understanding how FICPA fought back. Deregulation, she stresses, is bipartisan.

In red-leaning Florida, it’s about free-market enterprise. Republicans believe licensure creates too many barriers, too much red tape, and too much government interference. They want consumers to have more freedom of choice. They want more people to move to Florida and find work easily. They want more businesses to relocate there.

In blue and purple states, Democrats frame it as an issue of access and equity. If barriers are too high, they limit opportunities for disadvantaged groups. But the common thread between the two parties is the workforce. Everyone wants more people working and more businesses thriving.

“If you can take your CPA hat off for a moment, which I know is hard to do, you can understand where they were coming from,” Shelly said. She even acknowledges that “not all deregulation is bad and scary and ugly. There are a lot of deregulation proposals that, frankly, our profession and our license would be highly supportive of. We don’t want to be a barrier to entry. We’re the champions of efficiency.”

This particular bill, however, was “the most extreme version the profession had seen.”

After surviving the 2025 session by the skin of their teeth, FICPA had only a couple of months before facing the same threat again in 2026. They had to beat it twice, back-to-back.

The Two-Pronged Strategy That Saved the License

The bill moved at lightning speed. “From the time the bill was introduced until it passed the House floor was 18 days,” Shelly recalled. “It flew through three different committees, went to the House floor for a vote, and then got sent over to the Senate.”

FICPA knew early that the Senate would be their battlefield.

The resources they marshaled were impressive. Nine registered lobbyists worked the FICPA account, which included four in-house staff members (including Shelly herself) and an external firm they’d partnered with for 25 years. Two public affairs firms shaped their message in political trade journals. Voter polling projects studied constituent opinions. Members wrote letters, made calls, and traveled to Tallahassee.

But the smartest tactic was personal. FICPA hunted through its membership to find CPAs with genuine relationships with legislators. “We found college roommates, sisters, people that went to church together, anything you can imagine,” Shelly said. Why? “Hearing from a lobbyist is very different than hearing from, say, your own CPA on this issue.”

With these resources deployed, FICPA ran two strategies simultaneously.

First came the commerce argument. Florida’s system of mobility and practice privileges creates open borders for CPA work across state lines. It puts choice in consumers’ hands, which is exactly what deregulation advocates claim to want. So FICPA flipped the script. Pass this bill, and you don’t reduce red tape; you create it. “Florida’s going to be at a disadvantage,” they told lawmakers. “That’s not what you want.”

The argument “landed really, really well” and came up repeatedly in committee hearings.

The second strategy separated FICPA from every other profession in the bill. Instead of just defending the status quo, they modernized their own rules before the fight even started. “We asked ourselves before the bill even dropped: where and how can we, as a license, be more efficient while still upholding the integrity of our license and protecting the public?”

They examined everything from reciprocity and mobility to the licensure processes and introduced their own legislation to streamline it all.

Take reciprocity as an example. Currently, a CPA from another state must complete about nine steps to get licensed in Florida, including having their college transcript reviewed for specific courses. Shelly asked, “If they have a license in good standing from a board of accountancy that has a regulatory board, do we need to look under the hood and go through all of these different steps?”

Cutting that red tape “only helps people get to work easier and faster and lowers barriers,” which is exactly what legislators wanted, achieved on the profession’s terms.

Playing Offense and Defense at the Same Time

Shelly has a perfect analogy for what FICPA had to do. In Top Gun: Maverick, the pilots play “dogfight football” by running offense and defense simultaneously and trying to score while blocking linebackers coming after them. “That is the definition of what we’ve been doing over the past 12 months,” she said.

The key was avoiding becoming “the agent of no.” As Shelly explained, “I never want a legislator to see us walk in the door and be like, ‘Oh my God, here come the CPAs again, they’re going to complain about X, Y and Z.'”

Instead, the profession leaned into its identity as efficiency experts.

The Pathways initiative became powerful proof. The bill’s supporters argued that students learn more on the job than in the classroom, so why require education at all? FICPA didn’t have to argue theoretically. The profession had already created a work-experience pathway to licensure. It was a nationwide modernization effort states had rallied behind together.

FICPA could tell senators: we agree there should be freedom of choice, and here’s a pathway that prioritizes work experience. “It’s not an or, it’s an and. Let’s work together.”

That framing “landed very, very well” because it met lawmakers’ goals while protecting the system of commerce and the license’s integrity.

What made the difference was posture. FICPA was “the only profession in this particular bill that had taken a moment to self-reflect and taken a moment to modernize.” They were the only ones offering both sides a win.

The Midnight Drama and What’s Coming Next

Despite all the strategy, the fight came down to that single agonizing day, and it was the toughest of Shelly’s career. In Florida, any bill not passed by midnight on the session’s 60th day automatically dies.

On the final day of the 2025 session, with the House having already passed the bill, FICPA was “hanging on for dear life to prevent it from passing in the Senate.”

Standing in the Capitol rotunda, Shelly orchestrated a desperate defense. “We were literally physically pulling senators off the floor and just doing everything we could. I had every single CPA that personally knew one of the senior members of the Senate calling and texting and just physically pulling them aside.”

She credits Senator Joe Gruters, who is himself a CPA, as a crucial ally in that final stretch. Shelly calls him “the staunchest advocate for the profession.” The outcome stayed uncertain until the very end. The session ran “all the way to midnight,” and FICPA didn’t know they were safe until late in the evening. Since we recorded, Gruters was elected chair of the Republican National Committee, and he leaves the Florida Senate in November.

But surviving twice doesn’t mean it’s over. “I do not think the issue of deregulation is going away. Absolutely not,” Shelly said.

Florida faces an election year with a new governor, speaker of the House, and Senate president coming. It’s “an all new deck of cards,” as Shelly puts it. She expects licensing reform task forces, reduction requirements, and especially the CPE issue to resurface in Florida and other states. Since we recorded, one of those cards turned over: Byron Donalds and David Jolly won their August 18 primaries and face off for governor on November 3.

The CPE fight shows exactly what’s at stake. Shelly’s concern wasn’t that lawmakers wanted to examine continuing education. It was that they went straight to elimination. “They weren’t talking about modernization. They wanted to get rid of it altogether.”

FICPA isn’t opposed to CPE reform. “I think there’s a lot that we can do to modernize it, to make sure that the purpose of it is to make a more competent CPA,” Shelly said. But she insists any change must happen collectively across states, just like Pathways, so it doesn’t break the system of commerce.

Whether the board-elimination proposal itself returns is harder to predict. Fresh lawmakers create what Shelly calls “an amazing opportunity” to find common ground before a bill ever gets filed. But she won’t count it out. “That idea has been planted, and it’s landed. There are a lot of people who are still interested in that.”

The Playbook Every State Society Needs

FICPA’s survival story offers lessons that reach far beyond Florida. When faced with a bill that treated a CPA license as no more important than a cosmetology certificate, the instinct to dig in and fight everything would have been understandable and probably fatal.

What actually worked was the opposite. By combining a commerce argument that addressed lawmakers’ concerns with genuine reform of reciprocity and licensure rules, FICPA found common ground while still protecting the public and the integrity of the license.

The profession wins by acting like the efficiency experts CPAs tell their clients they are.

Deregulation is bipartisan and gaining momentum nationwide. Every CPA, EA, and bookkeeper has a stake in whether the license keeps its value. State societies stand on the front lines when these bills drop.

As Shelly put it, “pressure is a privilege.” The profession’s willingness to be efficiency experts rather than agents of “no” may determine whether the license survives the next wave.

This is Shelly’s first and only live interview on a two-year battle that barely made the national press. To hear the full strategy, the midnight drama, and her warnings in her own words, listen to the complete episode on the Earmark Podcast.

Accountants Rush to Adopt AI While Ignoring the Security Risks That Come With It

Earmark Team · June 19, 2026 ·

Nearly nine out of ten accountants using AI report positive returns. But another statistic is more troubling. Over half of accounting firms have experienced data breaches recently, yet fewer than half have guidelines for how AI handles sensitive financial data. The productivity gains are real, but so are the risks we’re ignoring.

Blake Oliver, host of the Earmark Podcast, recently sat down with David Jani, Senior Content Analyst at Capterra, to unpack Capterra’s 2026 Accounting Software Trends report. The survey of 500 U.S. accounting managers shows the profession has moved beyond testing AI and into territory where the gap between adoption speed and security readiness is becoming dangerous.

 

The Productivity Gains Are Real (With a Catch)

AI in accounting has crossed from experiment to standard practice. More than half of accountants now use AI in their accounting software, and it appears across all company sizes, not just enterprises with big tech budgets. As David noted, “We’ve gone beyond the point of it being companies testing the water with this stuff.”

The most common uses for AI are chatbots and AI assistants, followed by data entry automation and fraud detection. AI is also making headway in predictive analytics, cash flow forecasting, smart invoicing, and bank reconciliation. David described it as “a coalescence around analytics and process-driven tasks.”

The 89% positive ROI figure comes from two main benefits. Half of respondents cite productivity gains, and nearly as many report reduced errors. So firms see real time savings and quality improvements.

But 48% of accountants manually check every single AI output. Not spot-checking, but checking everything. And about a third catch errors in their AI outputs more than half the time.

How do you square 89% positive ROI with error rates that high? David’s practical take is AI is “creating some gains in some areas, creating some extra work in others,” but the net result stays positive. Even when you add review time, firms come out ahead. But he cautioned, “It’s important that businesses still keep a close eye on the ROI of these situations and confirm it is delivering those gains.”

Meanwhile, plenty of work remains manual. More than half of respondents still handle financial reporting through spreadsheets or manual processes. Accounts payable and receivable, billing, invoicing, and payroll are all heavily manual. And yes, 51% of accountants still use Excel or Google Sheets for financial data. As Blake observed, spreadsheets have survived 40 years and aren’t going anywhere soon.

The Security Gap No One’s Taking Seriously

While firms celebrate productivity wins, the security picture is alarming, and almost nobody seems concerned enough to act.

Consider 52% of accounting managers surveyed have experienced a data breach in the last two years. That’s more than half. While David doesn’t have data linking these directly to AI, what he found about AI and sensitive data should worry every firm leader.

“Most companies don’t have clear guidelines on how they use AI tools with sensitive data,” David revealed. Fewer than half (49%) have guidelines for employee and payroll information. Coverage of bank reconciliation and customer billing data is even lower.

The perception gap is striking. Nearly half view AI cybersecurity risk as “minor,” another 12% as “insignificant,” and only 3% as “critical.” This might be “why so many people don’t have guidelines. Unfortunately, they just don’t perceive the risks at play,” David said.

Blake painted a scenario that’s probably happening now. Someone uploads payroll reports into free ChatGPT, where the terms of service may allow the vendor to train on that data. “We really need to step up,” he said.

The risks go deeper. Blake raised the issue of prompt injection, which involves hidden text in documents that manipulates AI agents into leaking data or changing payment information. It’s sophisticated and hard to defend against. As David acknowledged, “It’s a very new and rather sophisticated way of extracting information from a company. We still don’t really know enough about it.”

David didn’t sugarcoat his advice. “Guidelines around this don’t seem like much, and obviously, everyone is rushing to get AI tools. But it’s a huge risk factor we need to address.”

AI Is Raising the Bar

If AI makes accountants more productive, you’d expect fewer jobs. But the data tells a different story, and it came as a surprise to David.

“Despite a lot of reports predicting the end of accountants, it’s not really what we found,” he said. Companies are adopting AI, but “it’s not necessarily affecting hiring decisions in the same way. A lot of companies are actually more focused on upskilling.”

Blake offered a historical perspective. The same panic hit when VisiCalc and Excel arrived 40 years ago, yet accounting jobs grew. When cloud computing transformed the industry, client accounting services didn’t shrink. Instead, it’s grown year over year for a decade.

The talent shortage persists, with 73% of firms reporting trouble with retention and hiring. The hardest roles to fill are mid-career positions. About a third struggle to find financial analysts, with specialized accountants (tax and cost accounting) close behind.

The paradox is AI actually increases the need for experienced professionals. Someone must review those AI outputs that are wrong half the time. Someone must understand the AI well enough to catch mistakes. Someone must manage the security implications. All that requires judgment and experience, and that’s exactly what’s hardest to hire right now.

The data backs this up. Upskilling existing staff is the dominant strategy at 40%, double the 21% using AI to fill staffing gaps. Traditional hiring sits at 31%, with graduate programs at 23%. The profession is betting on people, not automation, to solve its workforce problem.

Looking Ahead: Challenges and Choices

What keeps accountants up at night? Budgeting and forecasting in an uncertain economy tops the list, followed by figuring out how to use AI effectively. As David put it, firms are trying to understand AI “in a way that makes sense.”

David has specific advice for where firms should invest their AI dollars. Map investments to your particular needs rather than chasing trends. For general guidance, he pointed to data entry automation and predictive modeling tools, especially cash flow forecasting and analysis dashboards, as areas delivering the most value.

When asked to predict what might change by the 2027 survey, David hopes to see more firms with updated security guidelines. “I think as these tools become more mature, more people will update their guidelines, especially for handling sensitive data like payroll and cash flow,” he said.

A Gap Between Speed and Safety

The Capterra data shows the profession is getting AI both right and dangerously wrong. The 89% positive ROI is genuine. Firms are saving time and reducing errors, even after factoring in review burdens. But that headline obscures the fact that over half have experienced breaches, fewer than half have AI data guidelines, and most dismiss the cybersecurity risk as minor, even with threats like prompt injection that the profession barely understands.

AI isn’t solving the talent crisis either. It’s raising the bar for what accountants need to know, making experienced reviewers more critical while the mid-career talent shortage intensifies.

Firms must build guardrails, write guidelines, and invest in upskilling their people to successfully work alongside technology that’s powerful but imperfect.

Want to dig deeper into these findings? Listen to Blake’s full conversation with David on the Earmark Podcast, and earn free NASBA CPE while you’re at it. 

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Go to Next Page »

Copyright © 2026 Earmark Inc. ・Log in

  • Help Center
  • Get The App
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Press Room
  • Contact Us
  • Refund Policy
  • Complaint Resolution Policy
  • About Us