• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Earmark CPE

Earmark CPE

Earn CPE Anytime, Anywhere

  • Home
  • App
    • Pricing
    • Web App
    • Download iOS
    • Download Android
    • Release Notes
  • Webinars
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Authors
  • Sponsors
  • About
    • Press
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Jeremy Wells

The Estimated Tax Penalty Is a Timing Rule Most Clients Misunderstand

Earmark Team · November 16, 2026 ·

Sam’s 2025 tax liability was $24,000. He had no federal income tax withheld during 2025 and made his first estimated payment on January 15, 2026, when he paid the full $24,000. His return still showed a balance due to an underpayment penalty. Jeremy Wells, EA, CPA, has been there several times, even with clients due a refund.

In Episode 40 of Tax in Action, Jeremy works through estimated taxes, safe harbors and Form 2210. His central point is the penalty asks whether each installment was paid on time, not whether the tax was eventually paid.

Why Sam paid in full and still owes $586

An individual generally must make estimated payments when:

  • They expect to owe at least $1,000 after withholding and refundable credits, and
  • Withholding and refundable credits are expected to fall short of the required annual payment.

The penalty does not apply if the taxpayer had no federal tax liability for the prior year, the prior tax year covered 12 months, and the taxpayer was a U.S. citizen or resident throughout that year. A zero balance due on the prior-year return does not establish zero tax liability.

“The estimated payments depend on the shortfall, not the source for that period,” Jeremy says. An underwithheld W-2 employee can owe just like a sole proprietor.

The required annual payment is generally the smaller of 90% of the current year’s tax or 100% of the prior year’s tax. The prior-year option requires a filed return covering a 12-month tax year. Use 110% of prior-year tax if prior-year adjusted gross income exceeded $150,000, or $75,000 if the taxpayer files separately from their spouse for the current year.

Sam’s 2024 tax was $20,000, and he qualified for the 100% prior-year rule. That gave him a required annual payment of $20,000, compared with $21,600 under the current-year calculation. Under the regular method, each of his four required installments was $5,000.

“Tax” includes self-employment tax, net investment income tax (NIIT), alternative minimum tax (AMT) and Additional Medicare Tax not withheld. That trips up sole proprietors who forget SE tax.

Under the regular method, the four required installments are generally equal even though the payment periods vary in length. The penalty is calculated separately for each installment. The annual underpayment rate was 7% throughout the time Sam’s installments were unpaid, including the first 15 days of January 2026. Here’s how the penalty breaks down for the three installments he missed:

  • April: 275 days unpaid, $264
  • June: 214 days unpaid, $205
  • September: 122 days unpaid, $117

That adds up to $586. “Paying later doesn’t erase an earlier underpayment,” Jeremy says. It’s “less of a penalty and more of a timing rule.” Since earlier shortfalls accrue longer, “the preference should always be toward an earlier payment.”

Withholding is the one payment that travels back in time

Estimated payments count toward the next installment date. Section 6654(g) generally treats withholding as paid in four equal parts on the installment dates. Sam’s January 15 payment stopped the penalty from accruing on his earlier shortfalls, but he still owed the penalty for the days those installments went unpaid. Federal income tax withholding works differently. Under the default rule, $20,000 withheld during 2025 counts as $5,000 paid on each of the four installment dates, even if the full amount was withheld in December.

S corporation shareholder-employees can increase federal income tax withholding on wages the corporation already plans to pay. That withholding can cover some or all of the federal income tax attributable to their K-1 income.

If the corporation also increases gross wages, factor in any additional employer and employee payroll taxes before deciding whether the move is worth it. If the corporation already needs to pay additional wages to meet reasonable compensation requirements or support a retirement plan contribution, consider adjusting withholding on that payroll.

Plan it in October or early November, while there’s time for another payroll run or two. Jeremy warns, “This isn’t permission to manufacture or backdate payroll.”

Check the payment date of any prior-year overpayment applied to estimated tax

Check applied prior-year overpayments. If the prior year’s tax was fully paid before April 15, generally treat the credit as an April 15 estimated payment. If a later payment created the overpayment, use the date of that payment.

For example, if a client owes $10,000 for the prior year, pays $20,000 on May 1, and applies the $10,000 overpayment to the current year’s estimated tax, treat the credit as paid on May 1. It can stop the penalty from accruing on an unpaid April installment as of May 1, to the extent it covers the shortfall.

Other levers, and when they’re worth the effort

Annualized income installment method. Schedule AI (Box C on Form 2210) uses income and deductions for four cumulative periods to determine whether annualizing reduces the required installments for any of those periods. It suits lumpy income, like late-year capital gains, seasonal businesses, and large year-end retirement distributions. It requires actual income records. If annualizing reduces or eliminates the penalty, check Box C and attach Form 2210 with Schedule AI.

Cost-benefit check. These penalties usually run a few hundred dollars, maybe a couple thousand. Chasing records and running complex calculations may cost more than it saves, especially for clients who didn’t plan with you last year.

Early filing. Filing and paying in full by January 31 eliminates only the fourth-installment penalty. Few clients have documents that early.

Farmers and fishers. If at least two-thirds of the taxpayer’s gross income came from farming or fishing in either the current or preceding tax year, the taxpayer generally has one estimated tax installment due January 15. The required payment is generally the smaller of 66⅔% of current-year tax or 100% of prior-year tax. Or, the taxpayer can skip that installment and avoid the penalty by filing the return and paying the full balance by March 1, subject to the usual weekend and legal holiday rule.

Filing-status changes. If spouses filed separately in the prior year and file jointly this year, combine their prior-year taxes. If they filed jointly in the prior year and file separately this year, allocate the prior-year joint tax using the formula in IRS Publication 505. Check Box E only if the taxpayer filed jointly in exactly one of the two years and the prior-year amount on Form 2210, line 8, is smaller than the current-year amount on line 5.

State rules. Don’t assume states follow federal rules. California requires 30/40/0/30, and Virginia’s first payment isn’t due until May 1.

Don’t count on abatement

First Time Abate and the IRS’s Automatic Exemption from Penalty program do not apply to the estimated tax penalty. Section 6654(e)(3) allows the IRS to waive the penalty in two situations:

  • A casualty, disaster, or other unusual circumstance makes imposing the penalty inequitable.
  • The taxpayer retired after reaching age 62 or became disabled in the year the installments were due or the preceding tax year, and the underpayment was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect.

Separately, IRS disaster relief may postpone an estimated tax deadline for eligible taxpayers. Check the applicable disaster notice to see which installments it covers.

If none of the boxes in Part II applies, the preparer can leave the penalty line blank and let the IRS calculate and bill any penalty due, or calculate the penalty and report it on Form 1040. Either way, the preparer leaves Form 2210 off the return. Jeremy’s firm calculates and reports the penalty and gives the client a copy of the completed Form 2210 with an explanation. Relief, he says, is “almost impossible and generally not even worth the effort trying” unless there are serious extenuating circumstances.

Prevention is the whole game

For clients who regularly pay more than $500, or even $1,000, in penalties, a $300 to $500 projection might be worth it. Start by projecting what the client needs to pay by each installment date to avoid the penalty. A client who qualifies for the 100% prior-year safe harbor can choose to target 110% as a cushion against a larger balance at filing. Update the projection when the client’s facts change and scope the work separately from return preparation.

Some clients knowingly pay a couple hundred dollars of penalty to keep their cash. Jeremy doesn’t necessarily agree, but it’s their call.

The key takeaways from this episode are:

  • Compare both safe harbors and use the smaller one
  • Pay the required amount by each installment date
  • Before finalizing the penalty, check whether using actual withholding dates or annualizing uneven income would reduce it.
  • Don’t expect abatement
  • Scope projections as a separate service

Listen to the full episode for Jeremy’s walkthrough of Form 2210 and its worksheet.

How to tell whether a client’s tax position has substantial authority

Earmark Team · November 10, 2026 ·

Donna earns about $300,000 in W-2 wages. Her new short-term rental generated a $120,000 loss after a cost segregation study front-loaded depreciation. She wants that loss to offset her wages.

She’s read IRS publications and blog posts, listened to podcasts, and consulted AI. She’s convinced. Now you have to decide whether her position belongs on the return.

In Tax in Action, Jeremy Wells, EA, CPA, uses Donna’s case to explain what makes a tax position defensible. The answer depends on verified facts and recognized authority rather than the client’s confidence or the odds of an audit.

Useful research isn’t necessarily authority

A source can explain tax law accurately without establishing substantial authority. Jeremy points to Treasury Regulation § 1.6662-4(d)(3)(iii), which provides a closed list of recognized authorities:

  • Enacted statutes and proposed, temporary, and final Treasury regulations
  • Tax treaties and court opinions
  • Revenue rulings and revenue procedures, as well as IRS notices and announcements published in the Internal Revenue Bulletin
  • Congressional committee reports and certain other legislative history
  • Joint Committee on Taxation Blue Books, which explain tax legislation after enactment

By contrast, IRS publications, form instructions, articles, research services, professional advice, podcasts, and AI output are research aids. They may help you find authority, but they do not establish it themselves.

Jeremy applies that rule to his own show: follow the citations and read the underlying sources. That matters especially when AI supplies the summary.

Finding a recognized source is only the start. Next, decide how much it supports your client’s position.

Weigh the authority instead of counting citations

Jeremy distinguishes three standards:

  • More likely than not: Greater than a 50% likelihood that the position would be upheld
  • Substantial authority: Supporting authority is substantial relative to contrary authority
  • Reasonable basis: A lower standard than substantial authority that generally requires sound support from one or more recognized authorities.

“We’re weighing authority. We’re not necessarily counting them,” Jeremy says.

Weight depends on relevance to the facts, persuasive reasoning, the type of authority, and whether it remains good law. You cannot cherry-pick favorable cases and ignore similar cases where taxpayers lost.

These standards measure legal merits, not audit risk. That distinction is crucial because the level of support affects the substantial-understatement penalty.

Disclosure helps, but it has limits

For individuals, an understatement is substantial when it exceeds the greater of $5,000 or 10% of the tax required to be shown. The percentage drops to 5% if the taxpayer claims the section 199A qualified business income deduction.

If the understatement exceeds the applicable threshold, the penalty is generally 20% of the portion of the underpayment attributable to the substantial understatement.

For most positions, two routes can exclude the tax attributable to a disputed item from the understatement calculation:

  1. Substantial authority, without disclosure for this purpose
  2. Reasonable basis plus adequate disclosure of the relevant facts

These rules apply to the substantial understatement penalty. Other grounds for an accuracy-related penalty, such as negligence, are evaluated separately.

Disclosure generally uses Form 8275, or Form 8275-R for positions contrary to Treasury regulations. The IRS also specifies when reporting an item on the return itself is adequate disclosure. For tax years beginning in 2025 and filed on 2025 forms, see Rev. Proc. 2026-12. Tax shelters and certain reportable transactions face stricter rules.

Return preparers face a separate standard under § 6694(a). For most positions, the preparer needs substantial authority if the position is undisclosed, or reasonable basis if it is adequately disclosed. For tax shelters and reportable transactions subject to § 6662A, the preparer must reasonably believe the position is more likely than not to be sustained on its merits.

But disclosure has limits. As Jeremy puts it, “Disclosure can never cure inadequate legal support or substantiation for a position.”

Attaching a form doesn’t replace missing participation evidence or make an unsupported position defensible. Donna’s hours show why.

Donna’s claim turns on 35 hours

Donna’s 15 customer stays averaged six days. Under Temp. Reg. § 1.469-1T(e)(3)(ii)(A), an activity with an average period of customer use of seven days or less falls outside the definition of a rental activity for § 469 purposes. She therefore doesn’t need real estate professional status to potentially treat this loss as nonpassive.

But she still needs to establish material participation.

Under Temp. Reg. § 1.469-5T(a)(3), Donna meets this test if she participates for more than 100 hours during the tax year and participates at least as much as any other individual, including nonowners such as her property manager. Donna reports 145 hours; her property manager reports 115.

At first glance, she passes. Then we examine what she actually did. Her total includes 35 hours reviewing financial reports, analyzing investment returns, and researching tax benefits. Those are investor hours.

Under the rule Jeremy explains, work Donna performs in her capacity as an investor counts toward material participation only if she is directly involved in the activity’s day-to-day management or operations. In this example, Donna isn’t involved in those daily activities. Excluding the 35 hours leaves 110 qualifying hours, which is five fewer than her manager’s 115.

The key fact is her lack of day-to-day involvement, not simply that she hired a manager.

Jeremy already ruled out the other six material participation tests. He concludes that counting those investor hours lacks substantial authority and, in his view, even a reasonable basis. Disclosure can’t solve that problem.

On these facts, Donna’s short-term rental loss is passive and cannot offset her W-2 wages. Any portion of the loss disallowed under § 469 this year generally carries forward to the next tax year.

The research answered the question. Now the practitioner must explain and document the answer.

Build a file that explains your conclusion

Jeremy draws on Circular 230’s diligence framework. Practitioners can generally rely in good faith on information clients provide. If that information appears incorrect, inconsistent with an important fact or assumption, or incomplete, practitioners must make reasonable inquiries.

Use that approach to build a repeatable process:

  1. Establish the relevant facts. Define the issue before researching. In Donna’s case, ask what she did during the 145 hours she reported and what records support the time she spent on each task.
  2. Find the controlling law. Start with the Code and regulations; use research tools to locate relevant rulings and cases.
  3. Read both sides. Compare supporting and contrary authorities with the client’s facts.
  4. Assess support and evidence. Determine whether substantial authority exists or whether reasonable basis and disclosure are available.
  5. Document and advise. Record sources, reasoning, conclusions, and uncertainty. Explain the treatment and potential penalties to the client.

For Donna, that means explaining why the 35 hours don’t count and why the loss can’t receive the proposed nonpassive treatment. Offer to prepare the return using the passive-loss treatment. If Donna insists on treating the loss as nonpassive on these facts, decline to prepare or sign a return that takes that position.

Your answer should rest on the law and facts, not on whether you expect an audit.

Listen to Tax in Action, episode 39 to hear Jeremy work through Donna’s case and explain how to weigh the authorities that support and cut against a return position.

Section 225 doesn’t make overtime tax-free

Earmark Team · November 5, 2026 ·

“They say politicians campaign in poetry, but they govern in prose.” Jeremy Wells, EA, CPA, opens Episode 37 of Tax in Action with that line, and it frames the new overtime deduction well.

“No tax on overtime” is the poetry. IRC Section 225 is the prose.

Overtime isn’t exempt from tax. For tax years 2025 through 2028, eligible taxpayers may deduct a limited portion of qualified overtime compensation. The deduction requires a Social Security number (SSN) and comes with income limits, filing-status rules, and strict reporting criteria. Here is what tax professionals need to know.

“No tax” is really a limited deduction

Qualified overtime compensation is still part of gross income and subject to federal income tax withholding, Social Security and Medicare taxes, federal unemployment tax, and applicable state taxes.

But Section 225 created a temporary deduction on Schedule 1-A. Clients can claim it whether they itemize or take the standard deduction, but it doesn’t reduce adjusted gross income.

The main limits are:

  • $12,500 for single and head-of-household filers
  • $25,000 for married couples filing jointly
  • A reduction of $100 for each full $1,000 of modified AGI above $150,000, or $300,000 for joint filers
  • No inflation adjustment or carryforward for unused amounts
  • No deduction for married filing separately
  • An SSN valid for employment, issued before the return’s due date (including extensions), for each person whose overtime supports the deduction; an ITIN doesn’t qualify.

For this purpose, modified AGI adds back income excluded under Sections 911, 931, and 933. The income phaseout applies after the filing-status cap.

But before applying those limits, we must identify the qualifying compensation.

The tax answer starts with federal labor law

Qualified overtime compensation is the amount required under Section 7 of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) that exceeds an employee’s regular rate. For a covered, nonexempt employee, the FLSA generally requires time-and-a-half pay for hours over 40 in a workweek.

Under the usual time-and-a-half calculation, only the extra half-time premium qualifies. The employee’s regular wages for those hours don’t. Special rules apply to certain employees whose overtime is calculated under alternative provisions of FLSA Section 7.

Under the usual FLSA rules, each workweek stands alone. If an employee works 30 hours one week, 50 the next, and 35 the third, the employer can’t average the weeks. The 10 hours above 40 in the second week create the overtime obligation.

Voluntary premiums and amounts required only by state or local law don’t qualify beyond the federal minimum. Qualified tips, as defined in Section 224(d), are excluded from qualified overtime compensation, whether or not the taxpayer claims the tips deduction.

FLSA coverage is also a facts-and-circumstances question. Common exemptions include certain executive, administrative, professional, outside-sales, and computer roles. If an employee disputes their classification, refer the client to an employment attorney or HR professional. Our role is to understand the tax treatment and check the reporting.

Payroll labels can hide the qualifying amount

Jeremy’s examples involving an employee named Eve show why we can’t rely on the word “overtime” alone. Assume Eve is eligible for FLSA overtime, all listed amounts relate to hours subject to the usual federal overtime requirement, and the pay multiples use her FLSA regular rate. Under those assumptions, each record produces the same $5,000 qualifying amount:

  • $5,000 labeled as the FLSA overtime premium: Use $5,000
  • $15,000 of total time-and-a-half pay: Divide by three. Only $5,000 is the half-time premium.
  • $10,000 described as the premium above regular pay under a double-time plan: Divide by two
  • $20,000 of total double-time compensation: Divide by four

The FLSA regular rate isn’t necessarily the employee’s base hourly wage. It generally includes nondiscretionary bonuses, commissions, and other compensation unless a statutory exclusion applies. Employers and payroll providers don’t always use these terms consistently. Confirm whether the number represents total overtime pay, the full premium above regular wages, or the FLSA half-time premium.

Separate reporting becomes mandatory with tax year 2026

Because the law passed mid-2025, the IRS offered transition relief for that year only. Employers were encouraged, but not required, to identify qualified overtime separately. Employees could use pay stubs, Form W-2 Box 14, or one of the reasonable methods in Notice 2025-69.

For 2026, employers must report qualified overtime on Form W-2, Box 12, Code TT. A pay stub or Box 14 entry isn’t enough. In rare cases involving a worker treated as an independent contractor for income tax purposes but as an employee under labor law, the amount may appear in Form 1099-NEC Box 1d or Form 1099-MISC Box 14.

If an employer reports too little, the taxpayer must request Form W-2c. If the employer won’t provide a correction, the taxpayer cannot use the omitted amount to calculate the deduction. Form 4852 cannot substitute for employer reporting for this purpose. If the employer reports too much, the taxpayer still can’t deduct more than the qualifying overtime actually paid.

That makes payroll review an essential part of tax preparation.

The final deduction may be smaller than clients expect

The calculation follows three steps: determine qualified overtime compensation, apply the filing-status cap, and then apply the modified-AGI phaseout.

Jeremy’s examples show the result:

  • A single taxpayer with $15,000 of qualified overtime and $75,000 of modified AGI may deduct $12,500
  • At $175,000 of modified AGI, the same taxpayer’s deduction falls to $10,000
  • Joint filers with $15,000 of qualified overtime and $250,000 of modified AGI may deduct the full $15,000
  • At $450,000 of modified AGI, the phaseout reduces that couple’s deduction to zero

Because the deduction doesn’t reduce AGI, it doesn’t change premium tax credit calculations, IRMAA, taxable Social Security, net investment income tax thresholds, or other AGI-based provisions. It also doesn’t reduce FICA or self-employment tax. However, because it reduces taxable income, it can affect the qualified business income deduction’s taxable income limitation and thresholds.

Replace the slogan with a review process

Section 225 is a narrow, temporary deduction, not tax-free overtime. For each affected client:

  • Identify the FLSA-required half-time premium
  • Check filing status, modified AGI, and SSN eligibility
  • Reconcile payroll records with Form W-2, Box 12, Code TT
  • Request a corrected form when the reporting is wrong
  • Explain what the deduction will and will not change

Political slogans are memorable. Our job is to translate them into the numbers that go on the return. For Jeremy’s complete walkthrough, listen to Episode 37 of Tax in Action.

Your client lost it all at the casino, so why do they still owe tax?

Earmark Team · November 5, 2026 ·

Your client hands you a Form W-2G showing $75,000 of slot winnings. “I lost all of it,” the client says, “so there shouldn’t be anything to report, right?”

Jeremy Wells, EA, CPA, recently encountered a similar case at his firm. As the conversation unfolded, the client’s combined wins and losses potentially reached hundreds of thousands, possibly even millions, of dollars. So what belongs on the return? The $75,000, the full activity, or nothing?

In this episode of Tax in Action, Jeremy explains why the answer starts with the activity rather than the paperwork. Starting in 2026, even breaking even can produce taxable income.

Start with the wager, not the payout

Before calculating losses, determine whether the client’s income came from wagering. Neither Section 165(d) nor its regulations define a wager. Jeremy draws on the courts’ approach, which defines a wager as something of value placed at risk, with an uncertain outcome and a possible prize or return.

Skill doesn’t automatically rule out wagering, nor does an entry fee automatically establish it. Ask what the payment purchased. Was it access to a competition, or a stake in an uncertain outcome?

A paid raffle is a wager. A free promotional drawing isn’t, because the participant risks nothing. The prize is generally taxable under Section 61, but it doesn’t count as wagering gains that you can offset with gambling losses.

The stake also establishes basis. Bet $100 against a friend’s $100 on a coin flip and win the $200 pot. Your gain is $100, not $200. If you lose, your loss is the $100 wager.

Next, we need to decide how to measure that activity.

Measure sessions without netting the year

For slot play, courts and the IRS support session accounting rather than tracking every lever pull. Compare the amount available when the session ends with the amount brought into it. For example, if you start with $100 and leave with $200, you have a $100 gain. If you lose the entire stake, you have a $100 loss.

Jeremy cautions that this authority is strongest for slots. Don’t assume the same accounting unit fits poker, sports betting, or other activities.

“Session accounting isn’t annual netting,” he emphasizes. Consider three sessions:

  • Session one: $1,000 gain
  • Session two: $700 loss
  • Session three: $200 gain

Report $1,200 of gains and calculate the deduction from $700 of losses. Don’t report $500 of annual net income. For a casual gambler who itemizes in 2026, the loss deduction is $630 (90% of $700).

Those separate totals drive the new tax result.

The 2026 limit creates income without profit

Before 2026, Section 165(d) generally limited deductible wagering losses to wagering gains. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act adds another restriction starting in 2026, since deductible wagering losses equal the lesser of 90% of wagering losses or wagering gains.

Congress is considering legislation that would remove the 90% restriction retroactively for 2026. The examples below apply the law currently in effect; check for legislative changes before preparing returns.

For a casual gambler who itemizes:

  • Gains: $100,000
  • Losses: $100,000
  • Permitted loss deduction: $90,000
  • Taxable income remaining: $10,000

The client broke even financially, but not for tax purposes.

Joint filers combine both spouses’ gains and both spouses’ losses, keeping the totals separate before applying the limit. Taking the standard deduction means a casual gambler can’t deduct any losses. Some states don’t allow a wagering-loss deduction, and high-income taxpayers may face a further reduction in itemized deductions under amended Section 68.

Casual gamblers report gains on Schedule 1 and permitted losses on Schedule A. The gains increase adjusted gross income (AGI), but losses don’t reduce it. That mismatch can increase taxable Social Security, reduce income-based credits and deductions, and increase Medicare income-related premiums. Although casual gambling winnings generally aren’t net investment income, they increase MAGI and can expose more of the taxpayer’s other investment income to the net investment income tax. Jeremy flags the Medicare issue because many gamblers are retirees.

Professional gamblers use Schedule C, but that doesn’t remove the limit. Wagering losses and otherwise allowable wagering-related business expenses are still subject to Section 165(d). The law makes that expense treatment permanent and adds the 90% restriction. Professionals also pay self-employment tax on net earnings.

Professional status depends on regular, ongoing activity pursued for income or profit, not the client’s chosen label.

Reliable records must support the totals no matter which reporting path applies.

A W-2G tells only part of the story

A W-2G reports certain gambling winnings, not a complete accounting of the client’s activity. Depending on the type of gambling, the reported amount may already subtract the winning wager. Determine whether it includes any return of the client’s stake, then reconcile it with the records supporting the wagering or session result.

Jeremy shared an example. A client receives a W-2G for a $2,000 slot jackpot, starts the session with $500, and leaves with $1,600. Assuming the client added no funds and withdrew no winnings during play, the session gain is $1,100: the $1,600 remaining minus the $500 starting amount.

Ask for records instead of simply accepting the client’s explanation.

The reverse also happens. Smaller wins, sports bets that fail the 300-to-1 reporting test, cash play, and foreign or online activity can produce taxable gains without a W-2G. As Jeremy says, “These are information reporting thresholds. They aren’t income exclusion thresholds.”

So the preparation process must reach beyond the forms.

Build a return you can explain

Use Jeremy’s workflow to turn scattered paperwork into supported totals:

  • Identify all activity: Ask about every casino, sportsbook, app, and type of gambling
  • Gather the records: Collect W-2Gs, payer statements, and wager, session, and account histories
  • Separate gains and losses: Use the appropriate accounting unit, then apply the deduction limit
  • Reconcile the forms: Report the proper gain, claim reported withholding, and retain a form-by-form, session-by-session reconciliation. Consider attaching an explanatory statement.

Under Revenue Procedure 77-29, clients should log dates, activities, establishment names and locations, companions, and amounts wagered, won, and lost. Bank records, ATM records, player histories, and travel records supplement that log. Annual casino win-loss statements rarely provide the session detail needed.

“I lost it all” isn’t a reporting method. Establish basis, separate winning and losing results, and reconcile before applying the 90% limit. Educate clients now so their records can support the return later.

Listen to Jeremy explain the calculations and preparation workflow in Episode 38 of Tax in Action.

Three questions every tax firm should ask before new technology touches client files

Earmark Team · September 29, 2026 ·

Grady, the owner of Lighthouse Accounting LLC in the episode’s case study, has a capacity problem. In the previous episode of Tax in Action, he considered hiring employees, outsourcing work, or selling his firm. Now he’s asking, “What if technology could solve the problem?”

New software might automate some of the work. AI might reduce the need for seasonal staff. But adding technology creates its own risks, especially when client information leaves the firm.

In this episode, host Jeremy Wells, EA, CPA, explains why Section 7216 is only the starting point. Tax professionals must also consider the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), the FTC Safeguards Rule, their written information security program (WISP), vendor oversight, SOC 2 reports, and the professional duties that apply when AI helps perform the work.

Three questions connect these rules:

  1. May we share the client’s information?
  2. Are we protecting it appropriately?
  3. Is a human still exercising professional judgment?
 

Section 7216 is only the first layer

Section 7216 generally prohibits a tax return preparer from using or disclosing tax return information unless an exception applies or the taxpayer provides written consent.

One exception covers certain “auxiliary services.” Certain disclosures for auxiliary services connected with tax return preparation are permitted without taxpayer consent. These services can include processing, storage, transmission, and software support. But the exception is not blanket permission to share client information with any technology provider. Firms must evaluate the services performed, where information will be disclosed, and the conditions of the applicable exception. Special requirements can apply to overseas disclosures, substantive tax determinations, and certain software-support contractors.

Without that exception, Jeremy notes, firms might be stuck using pencil and paper.

But Section 7216 only governs the use and disclosure of tax return information. It doesn’t tell you whether your firm or the provider has adequate safeguards. And disclosure can include both an intentional transmission and an unauthorized release, such as a data breach or someone viewing client information over your shoulder.

Once you determine that a disclosure is allowed, you must move to protecting the information.

GLBA creates the duty to protect client information

The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act says financial institutions have an “affirmative and continuing obligation” to respect customer privacy and protect nonpublic personal information. It calls for administrative, technical, and physical safeguards that:

  1. Preserve the security and confidentiality of customer records
  2. Protect against expected threats or hazards
  3. Prevent unauthorized access that could cause substantial harm or inconvenience

GLBA appears in Title 15 of the U.S. Code rather than the Internal Revenue Code. It doesn’t specifically name accountants or tax preparers. Instead, the FTC’s regulations treat tax preparation firms as financial institutions because they engage in financial activities.

That means strict compliance with Section 7216 may not satisfy a firm’s broader information-security obligations. For those requirements, we must look at the FTC Safeguards Rule.

Your WISP should guide your technology choices

The FTC Safeguards Rule, found at 16 CFR Part 314, requires covered firms to develop, implement, and maintain a written information security program. The program must fit the firm’s size and complexity, the nature and scope of its work, and the sensitivity of the information it holds.

A solo practitioner and a national firm with 5,000 employees won’t need identical controls. That is why a generic WISP template isn’t enough. The document must reflect how your firm operates.

A WISP should address areas such as:

  • Risk assessment and security safeguards
  • Incident response
  • Employee training
  • Vendor selection and oversight
  • Document retention and secure disposal
  • Ongoing monitoring and updates

Some specific requirements have a small-firm exception. Firms maintaining customer information concerning fewer than 5,000 consumers are exempt from certain provisions, including the prescribed written incident response plan. They must still maintain a written information security program, and planning how to respond to an incident remains a sound practice.

The firm must also designate a Qualified Individual to oversee and implement the program. That person may work within the firm or for an affiliate or service provider, such as an outside IT firm. If the role is outsourced, the firm retains responsibility for compliance and must designate a senior employee to oversee the outside Qualified Individual. The affiliate or service provider must also maintain an information security program that protects the firm.

These duties apply whether your firm stores records in the cloud or in locked filing cabinets. Paper records still create questions about access, retention, destruction, and oversight of shredding providers.

Most importantly, software should conform to the WISP, not the other way around. Before adopting a new tool, ask what risks it creates, how you’ll manage those risks, who will oversee implementation, and whether you need to update the WISP. Because technology keeps changing, the WISP must be a living document.

That ongoing process also requires firms to evaluate the vendors behind their technology.

A SOC 2 report provides evidence, not certainty

The Safeguards Rule requires firms to take reasonable steps to select and retain service providers capable of maintaining appropriate safeguards, require those safeguards by contract, and periodically assess providers based on their risks and the continued adequacy of their safeguards.

Most firm owners can’t personally inspect a vendor’s servers, personnel, or access controls. A SOC 2 report helps fill that gap. In a SOC 2 engagement, an independent CPA examines controls related to one or more AICPA Trust Services Criteria: security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy.

There are two main report types:

  • Type 1 evaluates the design of controls as of a specified date
  • Type 2 evaluates both the design and operating effectiveness of controls over a period

A Type 2 report is generally more useful for an established vendor. Still, neither report certifies that a vendor is breach-proof. As Jeremy explains, it is “just one piece of evidence.” Firms should check the report type, the date or period covered, and whether the vendor continues to maintain its controls.

Vendor reports help with oversight, but they don’t transfer accountability away from the firm. The same principle applies when the technology uses AI.

Treat AI like a junior staff member

On June 24, 2026, the IRS Office of Professional Responsibility published OPR Alert 2026-19, its first guidance on artificial intelligence. Although the alert did not amend Circular 230 or create a separate set of AI rules, it explained how existing duties apply to AI-assisted work.

Those duties include due diligence, competence, supervision, written advice, and fees. Practitioners must still review client inputs and firm outputs, understand a tool’s limits, supervise AI-assisted workflows, and ensure written advice meets professional standards. 

The alert also cautions against billing for time not actually spent or double billing for AI-assisted tasks, and calls for transparency about AI-related cost savings. Jeremy emphasizes that firms using time- or cost-based billing should review whether their charges fairly reflect those efficiencies under the client agreement.

Jeremy recommends treating AI like a junior staff member, not an unsupervised practitioner or business partner. AI can draft client messages, support research, assist with return preparation, or perform bookkeeping tasks. It can also make mistakes, produce unsupported answers, and tell users what it thinks they want to hear.

Jeremy’s point is that professional judgment and responsibility remain with the human practitioner.

Keep three questions in every technology review

For Grady, choosing technology to expand his firm’s capacity means evaluating more than how much time a tool might save. He needs to establish whether he may share client information, how it will be protected, and who will review the work. The same three questions belong in every firm’s technology review:

  • May we share the information this way? Apply Section 7216 and determine whether an exception permits the proposed use or disclosure or valid taxpayer consent is required.
  • Are we protecting it appropriately? Follow a firm-specific WISP and continue monitoring vendors.
  • Are we still exercising professional judgment? Review the work and take responsibility for the result.

For Jeremy’s complete explanation and the rest of Grady’s case study, listen to Episode 36 of Tax in Action.

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 8
  • Go to Next Page »

Copyright © 2026 Earmark Inc. ・Log in

  • Help Center
  • Get The App
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Press Room
  • Contact Us
  • Refund Policy
  • Complaint Resolution Policy
  • About Us