Rachel Dillon’s January looked nothing like it used to. On the latest episode of Who’s Really the Boss?, recorded at the start of February, she and her husband, Marcus, reflected on surviving the chaos of 1099 season, year-end financials, and the opening weeks of tax prep. But for Rachel, this January brought something different. Her calendar was booked solid with prospect meetings from the moment the holidays ended through the last day of the month.
“This year was a little bit different,” Rachel shares. “My calendar from as soon as we came back from the holidays all the way through the last day of January was booked pretty solid with meetings with prospective clients.”
This wasn’t always the case. In fact, just a few years ago, the Dillons learned a painful lesson about relying too heavily on digital marketing when a website rebrand wiped out their entire online presence overnight.
When a Rebrand Breaks Everything
Back in August 2022, Marcus and Rachel made what seemed like a smart strategic move. They renamed their firm from Dillon CPAs to Dillon Business Advisors. The old name was attracting the wrong leads, mostly people looking for quick tax returns with no interest in advisory services.
“We got a lot of leads and phone calls, but they were all tax-related,” Marcus explains. “We just would filter through those, try to upsell people into CAS services when at all possible. But it was just a lot of no.”
Along with the new name came a new logo and a brand-new website at dillonadvisors.com. There was just one problem. Nobody properly redirected the old domain to the new one. Overnight, every bit of search engine authority they’d built since 2011 vanished.
“We went from three to four online form fills and probably four to five or phone calls per week with new prospects reaching out about services to zero, none,” Rachel recalls. “No phone calls, and no form fills.”
The silence was so complete that they weren’t even getting spam. If your contact form isn’t attracting junk submissions, Rachel notes, “that’s 100% sure, you know your website is not working.”
They waited three months before questioning it, trusting their consulting team’s assurance that new sites take time to gain traction. When they finally investigated, they audited the site with three or four different vendors. The one that ultimately helped them rebuild provided data no one else had surfaced.
The experience taught them valuable lessons. Always redirect your old domain—it’s non-negotiable. Get multiple website audits, and don’t accept vague promises about improvements. And if your leads drop to zero overnight, don’t wait to investigate.
Where Quality Referrals Really Come From
That website disaster forced Marcus and Rachel to rebuild their lead generation around something more reliable than search rankings: human relationships. And it worked. Those January meetings didn’t materialize out of nowhere. They were the result of relationships nurtured throughout the previous year, especially in Q3 and Q4.
When Rachel analyzes where their best leads come from, the same sources keep appearing: current clients who love their team. Professional referral partners like financial advisors, attorneys, and bankers. Personal network connections from church, the neighborhood, and mastermind groups.
“Most likely to sign and quickest to sign are people referred by others who know us,” Rachel says. Whether it’s a long-term client, a team member, or a financial advisor who shares mutual clients with DBA, trust transfers through that existing relationship.
Marcus developed a specific approach to cultivating these relationships. He tells referral partners exactly what capacity the firm has available. “I’ve got room for one more CFO-level client” or “I’m building the roster for this team member you may have met.”
“Having those conversations with people, whether it’s through email or just one on one over the phone or at lunch or coffee, that’s always very helpful because then they have a connection and want to help you,” Marcus explains.
He also ends every coffee or lunch meeting with the same question: “Is there anybody that you think I should meet?”
The Secret to More Referrals: Total Transparency
Rachel discovered that telling referral partners exactly what will happen when they send someone your way makes the biggest difference in referral quality and volume.
“Referral partners want to know exactly what’s going to happen when they refer the person to your firm. Who are they going to talk to? What timeline should I expect?” Rachel explains.
DBA has answered these questions so thoroughly that they created videos on their website walking through the process. Rachel can articulate the specific workflow. After an introduction, the prospect books a meeting with her through an automated calendar link. From that meeting, DBA requests access to QuickBooks Online and prior-year tax returns. Within five business days, the prospect receives pricing and recommendations.
Knowing their contact will have meaningful answers within one to two weeks makes referral partners far more confident about making introductions.
The firm also nurtures prospects between initial contact and the first meeting. Their website runs on HubSpot, which tracks what pages prospects visit and for how long. If there’s more than a week before the scheduled call, Rachel sends strategic content. That might be a blog article, the pricing page, or an explanation of their “Team of Three” service model.
“If they ask for payroll only, I want them to see those plans and pricing ahead of our conversation,” Rachel says. “Maybe they cancel because they don’t want all of that, or that pricing doesn’t align with what they think. That’s okay. That just means we haven’t wasted anyone’s time.”
How to Start Building Your Pipeline During Tax Season
Tax season might seem like the worst time to focus on business development. Marcus and Rachel disagree. They’ve identified several high-impact, low-effort strategies you can implement right now.
First, capture testimonials when gratitude is fresh. As returns go out and clients express appreciation, reply immediately. Either direct them to leave a Google review or ask permission to use their words as a testimonial. Marcus suggests creating a saved email signature with a direct link to your Google review page (the one that immediately pops up the rating box).
Second, document client wins before they disappear. Rachel recommends keeping a running list of specific outcomes, such as tax savings amounts, successful refinances, or time saved. “We forget those so quickly and easily, especially with the volume of work going in and out,” she notes. Set a goal for eight documented examples during the season.
Third, show up in person. Rachel recently spoke with three marketing professionals outside DBA, all of whom confirmed that in-person events outperform digital outreach for lead generation.
“Even though it feels like you should be doing something online that can cast out to hundreds or thousands of people, that doesn’t give the return that in-person events do,” Rachel explains.
The options go beyond formal networking events. Try study groups, chamber meetings, hobby gatherings, and church groups. Basically, anywhere your ideal clients naturally spend time. Marcus takes it further by inviting clients to events hosted by referral partners. The client gets continuing education credit, and Marcus stands in a room full of other ideal prospects.
If you think you don’t have time for this, Marcus has a pointed question. “Do you even have the capacity to serve new clients well?”
Start Where You Are
Building a referral pipeline doesn’t require a complete overhaul of your practice. It starts with small, deliberate actions that compound over time.
Rachel’s challenge is simple but powerful. “Start thinking about where your ideal clients hang out and how to get in those places. And if it’s not somewhere you necessarily want to be, then maybe reconsider your ideal client.”
Thriving firms don’t wait for leads to find them through Google searches or hope for referrals to materialize. They build relationships, educate partners, nurture prospects, and show up where their ideal clients already gather, even during the busiest seasons.
For Marcus and Rachel, that website disaster turned out to be a hidden blessing. It forced them to build something no algorithm change can destroy: a referral system built on trust, transparency, and genuine human connection.
Ready to hear the full conversation, including Marcus’s exact language for asking for introductions and Rachel’s specific HubSpot automations? Listen to the complete episode of Who’s Really the Boss?.
Rachel and Marcus Dillon, CPA, own a Texas-based, remote client accounting and advisory services firm, Dillon Business Advisors, with a team of 15 professionals. Their latest organization, Collective by DBA, supports and guides accounting firm owners and leaders with firm resources, education, and operational strategy through community, groups, and one-on-one advisory.
