At Nancy McClelland’s “Vulnerability as a Strength” panel at Scaling New Heights, the session opened with a word cloud. The question on screen was, “How does it make you feel when you think you’re the only one who doesn’t have it together?” Almost every answer was some version of “poopy” — alone, overwhelmed, not awesome. By the end of the session, the same room answered a different question. “How does it feel to realize you’re not the only one who struggles?” The screen filled with seen, validated, not alone, resilient, community. There were tears in that room. Nancy took a picture of the word cloud.
In Episode 33 of She Counts, Nancy and co-host Questian Telka talk about the two very different sessions they each led at that conference. Nancy ran a panel on vulnerability in leadership. Questian, along with co-presenter Ashley Rhoden, COO of High Rock Accounting, led a session on guiding clients and teams through change. When they compared notes afterward, they realized both talks made the same point. The strongest leadership skill in accounting isn’t having all the answers. It’s being willing to say out-loud what you don’t have figured out and staying curious enough to notice what your team and clients aren’t saying. As Questian put it, “Vulnerability is about recognizing and naming what’s happening inside of us. Change leadership requires us to recognize what is likely happening inside of someone else.” They’re two facets of the same muscle. Here’s how each one works, and why leadership happens in the messy middle.
Why admitting what you’re not good at makes you a stronger leader
Nancy has now run this panel twice. Both times, she started with what she calls a deeply invasive survey designed to reveal deeply rooted feelings and how people cope with them. Then she pulls out the common themes.
Patterns repeated across all six widely admired leaders: Every one had made a costly business decision. Every one had made a major client error. Every one had faced a physical or mental health crisis. The themes that came up included reconciling perception versus reality, building resilience through community, balancing control with letting go, finding meaning in the past, and managing stress and anxiety. These are the same coping strategies often used in cognitive and dialectical behavioral therapy.
There can be a huge gap between how leaders look and what they’re privately carrying. Questian described a friend telling her she “seemed to have everything perfectly together.” She nearly spit out her drink. “I feel like I’m falling apart most of the time.” Both hosts admitted they tend to share the hard stuff only after they’ve worked through it, like the woman who returned to a professional group after a long absence and explained, “It was just too hard to reach out while I was in the messy middle.” When leaders only share mistakes after they’ve been polished into a tidy success story, nobody gets to see the real scale of the failure, or how a person keeps going before they solve the problem.
The panelists were honest and specific about their weak spots, like conflict avoidance so strong it gets in the way, ADHD, the discomfort of hiring and firing, and the desire to be loved that makes holding people accountable genuinely hard.
So how do you admit a weakness without making your team fear for their jobs? Nancy’s answer, drawn from her panelists, is:
- Your team already knows where you’re weak. Pretending otherwise backfires.
- Name it, then ask for help. “You’re really good at this. I’m not. Do you have ideas for me?”
- Invite people with complementary strengths to help shape the firm’s future and offer the same support back. Mentorship goes both directions.
That same self-awareness makes you attentive to what’s happening inside someone else. And that’s where Questian’s session picks up.
Reading the change your client never announced
Questian’s practice is niched in nonprofits, where boards turn over constantly, and the decision-makers change with them. Change rarely arrives as an announcement. It usually shows up sideways:
- Slower response times
- Canceled meetings
- New, unfamiliar faces in meetings
- Shifts in who’s making decisions
- Unexpected reporting requests
- A client simply going quiet
She lost her first client that way. The organization was losing funding, responses stretched out, meetings got canceled, and eventually the executive director called to say they had to tighten their belts. In hindsight, the signs were all there.
Her advice is to meet regularly, build genuine rapport, and ask open-ended questions. What’s new? What’s changed? What are you planning for the next few months? Her questions, not their announcements, surface the most information. Nancy connected this to the “lead with curiosity” lesson from the Reframe conference: resisting the accountant’s instinct to jump straight to a solution. She also passed along a tip from Twyla Verhelst: before your next client meeting, run the transcripts of your last two or three meetings through an AI tool and ask what’s worth following up on. It’s not a substitute for rapport, but it’s a memory aid for when you have more client relationships than you can hold in your head.
This helps you become the person a client calls first. Change stops being a threat and becomes the doorway into advisory work. And as Questian pointed out, it’s far more expensive to find a new client than to grow a current relationship.
The messy middle is where leadership happens
Whether the change is internal, such as new technology, standardized processes, and documented SOPs, or on the client side, the hard part is emotional rather than technical.
Change happens in three parts: ending the old way, the messy middle, and the new beginning. “When you are in the messy middle,” Questian said, “that’s where we lose people and where we fail.”
Resistance almost always traces back to a fear of losing something, whether it’s control, expertise, authority, job security, or identity. Documenting SOPs so a team member can take a vacation without their laptop sounds like a gift until someone thinks, if you create those SOPs, then you can replace me. So get buy-in early, while feedback can still shape the decision. Frame the change as solving their problem. And remember that a launch date doesn’t come with an emotional switch. Questian described one team member who met her with resistance at every turn. She simply kept showing the benefit until they came out the other side and buy-in finally landed.
When a client’s needs shift, name it out-loud. Compare the original scope to the new outcome they’re after. Sometimes scope grows to support a negative. For example, helping a nonprofit evaluate cost cuts or a workforce reduction is a distinct project that deserves its own pricing. Center the conversation on the client’s needs, be transparent, avoid surprises, and lead with sensitivity, especially when the situation is painful. Absorbing unbilled, out-of-scope work “builds resentment,” Questian warned, “and it weakens the relationship.”
And there’s a bigger reason to get good at this. As Nancy argued in nearly every talk she’s given this year, as AI takes on more technical work, empathy and connection are more valuable than ever before. Trust and psychological safety stop being soft skills and start being the professional skills that set you apart.
Two questions to sit with
Nancy summed up her panel in three lines:
- No one has everything figured out
- Vulnerability doesn’t weaken leadership when it’s paired with responsibility and self-awareness
- You build resilience through community
Questian’s take is that relationships and scopes evolve when organizations evolve, and that evolution is an opportunity.
“Resilient firms aren’t built by people who never struggle,” Nancy said. “They’re built by people who don’t hide their struggles.” For women navigating rooms where they’re often the only one without a seat at the table, that reframe can mean pulling up a chair. Transparency is a professional strength, not a liability.
Nancy left listeners with an exercise. Write down every person who actually knows what you’re carrying right now. If the list is short, you’re not letting anyone in. Then flip it and ask yourself, “Whose load can you help lighten?” Or, as the hosts asked on LinkedIn, which side of leadership needs more attention from you right now, being more honest about what you’re carrying, or becoming more curious about what someone else is carrying?
They closed with a line from Nicole Davis, highlighted on one of Nancy’s slides from her SNH panel: “Vulnerability is a strength that the greatest leaders wear with pride.”
Listen to the full conversation between Nancy McClelland and Questian Telka and earn CPE credit for it on the Earmark app.
