• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Earmark CPE

Earmark CPE

Earn CPE Anytime, Anywhere

  • Home
  • App
    • Pricing
    • Web App
    • Download iOS
    • Download Android
    • Release Notes
  • Webinars
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Authors
  • Sponsors
  • About
    • Press
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Show Search
Hide Search

The Estimated Tax Penalty Is a Timing Rule Most Clients Misunderstand

Earmark Team · November 16, 2026 ·

Sam’s 2025 tax liability was $24,000. He had no federal income tax withheld during 2025 and made his first estimated payment on January 15, 2026, when he paid the full $24,000. His return still showed a balance due to an underpayment penalty. Jeremy Wells, EA, CPA, has been there several times, even with clients due a refund.

In Episode 40 of Tax in Action, Jeremy works through estimated taxes, safe harbors and Form 2210. His central point is the penalty asks whether each installment was paid on time, not whether the tax was eventually paid.

Why Sam paid in full and still owes $586

An individual generally must make estimated payments when:

  • They expect to owe at least $1,000 after withholding and refundable credits, and
  • Withholding and refundable credits are expected to fall short of the required annual payment.

The penalty does not apply if the taxpayer had no federal tax liability for the prior year, the prior tax year covered 12 months, and the taxpayer was a U.S. citizen or resident throughout that year. A zero balance due on the prior-year return does not establish zero tax liability.

“The estimated payments depend on the shortfall, not the source for that period,” Jeremy says. An underwithheld W-2 employee can owe just like a sole proprietor.

The required annual payment is generally the smaller of 90% of the current year’s tax or 100% of the prior year’s tax. The prior-year option requires a filed return covering a 12-month tax year. Use 110% of prior-year tax if prior-year adjusted gross income exceeded $150,000, or $75,000 if the taxpayer files separately from their spouse for the current year.

Sam’s 2024 tax was $20,000, and he qualified for the 100% prior-year rule. That gave him a required annual payment of $20,000, compared with $21,600 under the current-year calculation. Under the regular method, each of his four required installments was $5,000.

“Tax” includes self-employment tax, net investment income tax (NIIT), alternative minimum tax (AMT) and Additional Medicare Tax not withheld. That trips up sole proprietors who forget SE tax.

Under the regular method, the four required installments are generally equal even though the payment periods vary in length. The penalty is calculated separately for each installment. The annual underpayment rate was 7% throughout the time Sam’s installments were unpaid, including the first 15 days of January 2026. Here’s how the penalty breaks down for the three installments he missed:

  • April: 275 days unpaid, $264
  • June: 214 days unpaid, $205
  • September: 122 days unpaid, $117

That adds up to $586. “Paying later doesn’t erase an earlier underpayment,” Jeremy says. It’s “less of a penalty and more of a timing rule.” Since earlier shortfalls accrue longer, “the preference should always be toward an earlier payment.”

Withholding is the one payment that travels back in time

Estimated payments count toward the next installment date. Section 6654(g) generally treats withholding as paid in four equal parts on the installment dates. Sam’s January 15 payment stopped the penalty from accruing on his earlier shortfalls, but he still owed the penalty for the days those installments went unpaid. Federal income tax withholding works differently. Under the default rule, $20,000 withheld during 2025 counts as $5,000 paid on each of the four installment dates, even if the full amount was withheld in December.

S corporation shareholder-employees can increase federal income tax withholding on wages the corporation already plans to pay. That withholding can cover some or all of the federal income tax attributable to their K-1 income.

If the corporation also increases gross wages, factor in any additional employer and employee payroll taxes before deciding whether the move is worth it. If the corporation already needs to pay additional wages to meet reasonable compensation requirements or support a retirement plan contribution, consider adjusting withholding on that payroll.

Plan it in October or early November, while there’s time for another payroll run or two. Jeremy warns, “This isn’t permission to manufacture or backdate payroll.”

Check the payment date of any prior-year overpayment applied to estimated tax

Check applied prior-year overpayments. If the prior year’s tax was fully paid before April 15, generally treat the credit as an April 15 estimated payment. If a later payment created the overpayment, use the date of that payment.

For example, if a client owes $10,000 for the prior year, pays $20,000 on May 1, and applies the $10,000 overpayment to the current year’s estimated tax, treat the credit as paid on May 1. It can stop the penalty from accruing on an unpaid April installment as of May 1, to the extent it covers the shortfall.

Other levers, and when they’re worth the effort

Annualized income installment method. Schedule AI (Box C on Form 2210) uses income and deductions for four cumulative periods to determine whether annualizing reduces the required installments for any of those periods. It suits lumpy income, like late-year capital gains, seasonal businesses, and large year-end retirement distributions. It requires actual income records. If annualizing reduces or eliminates the penalty, check Box C and attach Form 2210 with Schedule AI.

Cost-benefit check. These penalties usually run a few hundred dollars, maybe a couple thousand. Chasing records and running complex calculations may cost more than it saves, especially for clients who didn’t plan with you last year.

Early filing. Filing and paying in full by January 31 eliminates only the fourth-installment penalty. Few clients have documents that early.

Farmers and fishers. If at least two-thirds of the taxpayer’s gross income came from farming or fishing in either the current or preceding tax year, the taxpayer generally has one estimated tax installment due January 15. The required payment is generally the smaller of 66⅔% of current-year tax or 100% of prior-year tax. Or, the taxpayer can skip that installment and avoid the penalty by filing the return and paying the full balance by March 1, subject to the usual weekend and legal holiday rule.

Filing-status changes. If spouses filed separately in the prior year and file jointly this year, combine their prior-year taxes. If they filed jointly in the prior year and file separately this year, allocate the prior-year joint tax using the formula in IRS Publication 505. Check Box E only if the taxpayer filed jointly in exactly one of the two years and the prior-year amount on Form 2210, line 8, is smaller than the current-year amount on line 5.

State rules. Don’t assume states follow federal rules. California requires 30/40/0/30, and Virginia’s first payment isn’t due until May 1.

Don’t count on abatement

First Time Abate and the IRS’s Automatic Exemption from Penalty program do not apply to the estimated tax penalty. Section 6654(e)(3) allows the IRS to waive the penalty in two situations:

  • A casualty, disaster, or other unusual circumstance makes imposing the penalty inequitable.
  • The taxpayer retired after reaching age 62 or became disabled in the year the installments were due or the preceding tax year, and the underpayment was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect.

Separately, IRS disaster relief may postpone an estimated tax deadline for eligible taxpayers. Check the applicable disaster notice to see which installments it covers.

If none of the boxes in Part II applies, the preparer can leave the penalty line blank and let the IRS calculate and bill any penalty due, or calculate the penalty and report it on Form 1040. Either way, the preparer leaves Form 2210 off the return. Jeremy’s firm calculates and reports the penalty and gives the client a copy of the completed Form 2210 with an explanation. Relief, he says, is “almost impossible and generally not even worth the effort trying” unless there are serious extenuating circumstances.

Prevention is the whole game

For clients who regularly pay more than $500, or even $1,000, in penalties, a $300 to $500 projection might be worth it. Start by projecting what the client needs to pay by each installment date to avoid the penalty. A client who qualifies for the 100% prior-year safe harbor can choose to target 110% as a cushion against a larger balance at filing. Update the projection when the client’s facts change and scope the work separately from return preparation.

Some clients knowingly pay a couple hundred dollars of penalty to keep their cash. Jeremy doesn’t necessarily agree, but it’s their call.

The key takeaways from this episode are:

  • Compare both safe harbors and use the smaller one
  • Pay the required amount by each installment date
  • Before finalizing the penalty, check whether using actual withholding dates or annualizing uneven income would reduce it.
  • Don’t expect abatement
  • Scope projections as a separate service

Listen to the full episode for Jeremy’s walkthrough of Form 2210 and its worksheet.

Podcasts Jeremy Wells, Tax In Action

Copyright © 2026 Earmark Inc. ・Log in

  • Help Center
  • Get The App
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Press Room
  • Contact Us
  • Refund Policy
  • Complaint Resolution Policy
  • About Us