When BDO threatened to sue a one-person blog for questioning its independence, it sparked a conversation about private equity’s growing influence in accounting. In this episode of The Accounting Podcast, hosts Blake Oliver and David Leary discuss this controversy along with Trump’s costly tariff policies, the profession’s hiring challenges, and a Hollywood accounting scandal.
The BDO-Going Concern Dispute
The accounting world is buzzing about BDO’s cease-and-desist letter to Going Concern, a one-person blog run by Adrienne Gonzalez. The dispute started when Going Concern’s Monday morning news brief linked to Bloomberg’s reporting about BDO cutting jobs while managing its debt to Apollo Global Management.
Here’s what happened: BDO took on $1.3 billion in debt from Apollo at 9% interest to fund an employee stock ownership plan. Apollo was also shorting First Brands Group, a company BDO was auditing. When First Brands suddenly collapsed without BDO issuing a going concern warning, Apollo made money on its short position.
Going Concern embedded a tweet connecting these dots, and BDO responded with legal threats demanding a retraction. Blake pointed out the irony: “You do this and now we’re talking about it. We wouldn’t have talked about it again this week. It was last week’s story. It became news again this week.”
The core issue isn’t whether BDO did anything wrong—there’s no evidence they did. It’s about appearance. As Blake explained, “You have to be independent in both fact and appearance. BDO may be independent in fact, but are they in appearance?” When your auditor owes money to a firm that’s betting against your audit clients, questions naturally arise.
Private Equity’s Rapid Expansion
The BDO situation reflects a broader trend that’s transforming the accounting profession. Since 2021, 24 of the top 100 U.S. accounting firms have taken private equity money. Even Crowe, which publicly rejected PE investment for years, is now hiring investment banks to explore selling a stake.
David warned about the pace of change. “When things are going too fast, people are not making sound decisions.” He pointed to the Citrin Cooperman deal as an example of potential conflicts. The PE firm that invested in them owns music catalogs, while Citrin Cooperman specializes in valuing music catalogs. A music industry blog picked up on this potential conflict, leading David to observe, “If somebody in the music industry is recognizing there might be independence issues, it’s a problem.”
Adding to the irony, BDO Global is now telling member firms to avoid taking external equity investments to preserve “independence and sustainable future,” even while BDO US remains tied to Apollo.
Trump’s Tariff Troubles
While accounting firms grapple with independence, businesses are dealing with expensive new trade policies. The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear arguments on whether Trump’s tariffs amount to an illegal $3 trillion tax on Americans. Lower courts have already ruled Trump exceeded his authority by imposing 10-50% tariffs through emergency declarations.
The real-world impact is already visible. Retail prices jumped 4.9% above pre-tariff trends in eight months. Coffee and tea prices rose 7.5%, while apparel increased nearly 9%. Both imported and domestic goods are getting more expensive, as domestic producers raise prices when foreign competition becomes costlier.
Small businesses face particular challenges beyond just higher costs. Blake shared a quote from David Zampierin, owner of Zamp Racing, a company that makes racing equipment. “I’ve been doing this for 40 years and it’s never been this complicated,” Zampierin told Accounting Today. Companies now spend hours on simple import documentation, and if businesses can’t prove where aluminum originated, customs assumes it’s Russian and charges a 200% tariff.
The Profession’s Mixed Signals
Despite these challenges, accounting firms remain optimistic about hiring. According to an AICPA survey, 75% of firms that hired in 2024 plan to maintain or increase hiring this year. However, they’re recruiting from a shrinking pool. Accounting graduates dropped 6.6% to just 55,000 students, with master’s programs declining 15%.
There’s a bright spot: accounting enrollment has surged 12% for two straight semesters, suggesting the pipeline might be recovering. But the profession’s image problem persists. U.S. News & World Report ranked accounting 90th out of 100 best jobs, with a median salary just under $80,000. The profession scored poorly on future prospects (4.3 out of 10) and work-life balance (5.1 out of 10).
The traditional career path is also changing. Only 38% of graduates now start in public accounting, down from 55% in 2014. Blake predicts this shift will continue. “Most accounting grads go into private industry, but we need experienced people in public accounting to do audits.”
Technology Updates
On the technology front, firms are embracing AI despite implementation challenges. AI adoption in audit jumped from 8% to 21% in one year, with early adopters reporting up to 40% productivity gains. However, most companies remain stuck in what researchers call the “middle maturity trap,” investing heavily but struggling with execution.
Several platforms announced updates. Keeper is rebranding to Double after settling a lawsuit over the name. BILL is partnering with NetSuite and Acumatica for embedded bill pay, though they’re also cutting 140 employees (6% of workforce). Canopy launched AI-powered client intake that predicts needed documents and auto-fills known information.
A Hollywood Fraud Scandal
In fraud news, a Los Angeles film production accountant was charged with embezzling nearly $2 million. Joshua Mandel, owner, CEO, and CFO of First J Productions, moved funds between productions to hide his theft, funneling money through an account he named “Fun Fun Fun.” He spent the money on Vegas trips and payments to adult film performers he met online. He faces up to 20 years per count if convicted.
Looking Ahead
Can firms maintain independence while taking private equity money? Will traditional safeguards survive this ownership transformation? As David warned, “We’re probably going to have another Enron here. We’re going to have an Arthur Anderson issue eventually.”
Blake emphasized what’s at stake: “The integrity of auditors is all that’s holding up our financial system.” With nearly a quarter of top firms now tied to private equity and more joining weekly, the profession must figure out how to preserve independence in this new reality.
The BDO/Going Concern dispute may seem like a small skirmish, but it represents a larger battle over accounting’s soul. When firms owe money to companies betting against their audit clients, when ownership structures become too complex to untangle, and when legal threats replace transparency, the profession’s core value—independence—comes into question.
Listen to the full episode to hear Blake and David’s analysis of these stories and more, recorded live from Intuit Connect in Las Vegas.